Factors influencing the recruitment and retention of registered nurses in adult community nursing services: an integrative literature review

Abstract

Background: Adult community nursing services are evolving around the world in response to government policies and changing patient demographics. Amidst these changes, recruitment and retention of community nursing staff are proving a challenge. An integrative literature review has identified multiple factors that influence nurse retention in adult community nursing with sparse information on recruitment factors. Although factors impacting retention of community nurses have been identified, their generalisability around the world is a challenge as they are context and co-dependent. Indicating the need for this area of study to be explored at a local level, as the same factors present with different findings globally. Aim: To establish factors influencing recruitment and retention of registered nurses in adult community nursing services. Design: Integrative literature review. Data sources: Four electronic databases were searched in August 2019 from January 2008 to December 2018: CINAHL Complete, Web of Science, MEDLINE and PROQUEST. Both qualitative and quantitative studies focusing on factors influencing community nursing recruitment and retention were included. Review methods: An integrative literature review methodology by Whittemore and Knafl (The integrative review: updated methodology. Journal of Advanced Nursing 52, 546–553) was followed, supported by Cochrane guidelines on data synthesis and analysis using a narrative synthesis method. The Center for Evidence-Based Management (CEBMa) critical appraisal tools were used for study quality assessment. Results: Ten papers met the study inclusion criteria. Data synthesis and analysis revealed individual and organisational factors influencing the retention of community nurses with the following three dominant themes: (1) work pressure, (2) working conditions and (3) lack of appreciation by managers. Conclusion: The review identified context-dependent factors that influence adult community nurses’ retention with limited generalisability. There is a lack of data on factors influencing recruitment into adult community nursing; further research is needed to explore factors affiliated to community nursing recruitment.

Should I stay or should I go? Why nurses are leaving community nursing in the UK

“…Although reviews on the subject tend to be exclusively focused on the acute nursing workforce, it is worth noting here that evidence supporting enhanced mentorship, increased access to supervision, team cohesion and orientations, interventions and leadership behaviour interventions, are seen to improve retention [ 18 , 29 ]. In a community context Chamanga et al, point to enhanced teamwork, access to education, improving work-life balance and appreciation by managers, as factors that increased retention for nurses [ 30 ]. Whilst these interventions show some promise and do begin to address some of the concerns expressed by nurses in our study, the quality of the evidence is relatively poor.…”

Identifying the Top Ten Unanswered Questions in Community Nursing: A James Lind Alliance Priority Setting Partnership in Community Nursing

“…Many of the nursing focused questions relate to retention, recruitment, and wellbeing issues. It is crucial that care and attention be paid to these very real and fundamental community nursing workforce challenges [36] if long term, sustainable changes to patient care are to be made.…”

Quality Matters: Examining the Impact of Nurse Staffing Challenges on Clinical Outcomes

“…At present, recruiting and retaining bedside nurses of all educational levels and backgrounds is challenging (Chamanga et al, 2020). Nursing shortages are reaching new heights in the United States (Zhavoronkova et al, 2022).…”