Steps in the replication of HIV-1 occurring in the virus, but not the host are preferred targets of anti-retroviral therapy. Strand transfer is unique; the DNA strand being made by viral reverse transcriptase (RT) is moved from one RNA template position to another.1 Understanding the mechanism requires knowing whether the RT directly mediates the template exchange, or dissociates during the exchange, so that it occurs by polymer dynamics. Earlier work in vitro showed that the presence of an RT-trapping polymer would allow synthesis on the original or donor template, but completely block transfer and subsequent synthesis on the second or acceptor template. One interpretation is that the RT must dissociate during transfer, but an alternative is that sequestration of non-polymerizing RTs prevents polymerization-independent ribonuclease H (RNase H) cleavages of the donor template necessary for strand exchange. To resolve this ambiguity, we designed a primer-template system that allows strand transfer without RNase H activity. Using an RNase H negative mutant RT, we showed that a polymer trap still prevented strand transfer. This confirms that RT dissociates during strand transfer. The presence of HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein, which promotes strand exchange, had little effect on this outcome. Additional assays showed that both, the wild type RT and a multiple NRTI resistant HIV-1 RT, containing an extended fingers domain, which is characterized by its enhanced primer-template binding affinity, were both unable to transfer with the trapping polymer. This implies that common sequence variations among RTs are unlikely to alter the dissociation feature.