Family Involvement in Asian American Health Interventions: A Scoping Review and Conceptual Model

Abstract

Family members play a crucial role in the health of Asian American communities, and their involvement in health interventions can be pivotal in optimizing impact and implementation. To explore how family members can be effectively involved in Asian American health interventions and develop a conceptual framework of methods of involvement at the stages of intervention development, process, and evaluation, this scoping review documented the role of Asian American family members in interventions (across any health objective). Of the 7175 studies identified through database and manual searches, we included 48 studies in the final analysis. Many studies focused on Chinese (54%) or Vietnamese (21%) populations, were conducted in California (44%), and involved spouses (35%) or parents/children (39%). We observed involvement across 3 stages: (1) intervention development (formative research, review process, material development), (2) intervention process (recruitment, receiving the intervention together, receiving a parallel intervention, enlisting support to achieve goals, voluntary intervention support, agent of family-wide change, and participation gatekeepers), and (3) intervention evaluation (received evaluation together, indirect impact evaluation, and feedback during intervention). Impact of family member involvement was both positive (as sources of encouragement, insight, accountability, comfort, and passion) and negative (sources of hindrance, backlash, stigma, obligation, and negative influence). Suggestions for future research interventions include (1) exploring family involvement in South Asian or young adult interventions, (2) diversifying types of family members involved (eg, extended family), and (3) diversifying methods of involvement (eg, family members as implementation agents).

Community health workers’ barriers and facilitators to use a novel mHealth tool for motivational interviewing to improve adherence to care among youth living with HIV in rural Nepal

“…It is likely that CHWs were able to build rapport with the clients and their families given their strong presence in the community and being seen as trusted members of the healthcare team [ 44 ]. Our experiences have also shown the need to engage with the family members of YLWH, especially in the South Asian context, where parents are the primary caregivers and decision makers and their voices become important for young people to participate in studies [ 45 , 46 ].…”

Understanding the factors related to how East and Southeast Asian immigrant youth and families access mental health and substance use services: A scoping review

“…The results of this review extended prior research on Asian immigrant youth MHSU by identifying factors related to how MHSU services are accessed rather than the state of Asian immigrant MHSU and/or MHSU service access [ 173 , 216 – 219 ]. Moreover, while there have been reviews of evidence related to mental health status and the influence of cultural and social factors on mental health among Asian immigrants, there has not yet been a review focused specifically on factors influencing how East and Southeast young people access MHSU services [ 10 , 12 , 34 , 201 , 220 – 229 ]. Furthermore, by identifying factors that influence how East and Southeast Asian immigrant youth access MHSU services, findings can inform the development of culturally-safe MHSU services for this population [ 37 , 230 , 231 ].…”

Family-centered decision making: A culturally responsive collaborative approach among Asians living in the United States.

“…Competence, similarly, encompasses not only an individual’s skills and capabilities but also their ability to fulfill social responsibilities, maintain positive relationships, and contribute to the greater good of all (Hwang, 2012; Markus & Kitayama, 1994; Rui, 2015). And relatedness is as well further enhanced by including important sources of social support, such as parents and children, in the process, as opposed to relying exclusively on providers (Ali et al, 2023; Chun & Akutsu, 2009).…”