Family Leave and Return-to-Work Experiences of Physician Mothers

Abstract

IMPORTANCE With the substantial increase in the proportion of women graduating from medical school, factors surrounding family leave require careful attention. Although many circumstances and experiences are unique to the training setting and specialty, a nationwide representation of physician mothers across all disciplines and all levels of training may reveal common themes and experiences among them, enable comparison across training setting and subspecialties, and identify best practices for supporting physician mothers throughout their careers. OBJECTIVE To characterize family leave and return-to-work experiences of physician mothers across subspecialties. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS This cross-sectional US nationwide survey study evaluating the experiences of 844 physician mothers was administered electronically via REDCap from September 2 to December 20, 2018. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES A survey was developed using a modified Delphi process with a panel of experts to characterize physician mothers' family leave and return-to-work experiences. The survey covered both negative and positive experiences of physician mothers for each child they conceived or adopted after medical school to identify areas for change and strategies for successfully supporting physician parents. RESULTS Of 1465 potentially eligible survey respondents, 844 (57.6%) were verified as unique respondents with complete surveys. Their mean (SD) age was 35.8 (5.2) years (range, 27-67 years), with most women (826 [97.9%]) currently practicing and 138 women (16.4%) currently in a residency program. Participants were included from 19 subspecialty groups. Of the women surveyed, 619 (73.3%) felt that leave time was insufficient. The majority (751 [89.0%]) would have preferred 11 weeks to 6 months of leave vs the 5 to 12 weeks (often not paid) most commonly available. The most frequently reported negative experiences when returning to work were associated with lack of facilities for breast pumping (range, 12 of 78 [15.4%] for the third child to 272 of 844 [32.2%] for the first child) and time for breast pumping (range, 27 of 78 [34.6%] for the third child to 407 of 844 [48.2%] for the first child), difficulty obtaining childcare (eg, for the first child, 298 of 844 [35.3%]), and discrimination (eg, for the first child, 152 of 844 [18.0%]). The most common positive experience was emotional support (eg, for the first child, 504 of 844 [59.7%]), primarily from colleagues. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE The present study, capturing one of the largest and most heterogeneous samples of physician mothers, showed that a substantial number of women physicians working in a variety of specialties at all levels of training across the United States needed and wanted more support for maternity leave and return to work. Support at the institutional level, such as paid leave, adequate breast pumping time without penalty, on-site childcare, and schedule (continued) Key Points Question What do physician mothers experience when taking maternity leave and returning ...

National survey of Canadian residents and program directors regarding parental leave during residency

“…A 30% response rate is typical for studies using online questionnaires that are able to directly contact the entire target population. 7,8,9 The study was reviewed and approved by the Health Research Ethics Authority (HREA) at Memorial University of Newfoundland. Consent was implied when participants clicked 'next page' after reading the information page, and this was outlined in the information page description.…”

“…3,4 Although residency may be an optimal time to have a child due to financial support and protected time for parental leave, numerous studies have found that many resident parents struggle with numerous challenges associated with taking parental leave during residency (see Finch, 2003, 1 and Humphries et al, 2017, 5 for a review). [6][7][8][9][10][11] Within Canada, studies investigating the challenges of having children during residency have been limited to surveys of residents in either a specific residency program, such as Obstetrics and Gynecology, 10,12 General Surgery, 11 Psychiatry, 13 and Family Medicine, 14 or a specific province, such as Québec. 15,16 One of the first qualitative studies to explore the struggles associated with taking a parental leave during residency in Canada showed that female family medicine residents felt their greatest challenges occurred in the first few months of returning to residency.…”

Ensuring Equity in Compensation and Career Advancement for Female Physicians

“…For both women and men, daycare is a family issue, and the importance of institutional attention cannot be underestimated. 10 Implementation of term limits for leadership positions (eg, department chairs, division directors) 11 can open the door to women's advancement. Access to sponsorship for leadership positions has long been a major hurdle for women.…”

Experiences of breast feeding at work for physicians, residents and medical students: a scoping review

“…9 Despite legal protections in many countries that require workplaces to support breast feeding, women physicians have lower rates of meeting their breastfeeding duration goals compared with women in other fields 10 and consistently report important systems-level barriers to breastfeeding. 11 We sought to synthesise the current literature examining breast feeding for women in medicine.…”