Fear and loathing in New England: examining the health-care perspectives of homeless people in rural areas

Abstract

Little anthropological research has been conducted on the health care perspectives of homeless people in rural areas. The aim of the present study is to elicit health-care beliefs, and examine overall health experience among a sample of current or recently homeless people in rural New Hampshire. Thirteen qualitative interviews were conducted, 11 with single men. Interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed, and analyzed using thematic analysis. Despite a massive burden of disease and illness, almost all participants reported an abiding aversion to doctors, hospitals and professional health care. Participants reported numerous negative encounters with doctors and health care professionals, often of a demeaning and disparaging nature. Participants noted that these encounters resulted in frequent cases of misdiagnosis and iatrogenesis. In contrast, participants spoke more fondly of other social and voluntary services, for example homeless organizations. Like other rural New Englanders, participants made their own individual efforts to maintain and promote health, for example by pursuing hobbies or prayer. The findings are contextualized within literature suggesting that these perspectives are generally shared by other poor rural people. Consistent with this literature, the findings suggest that homelessness in rural areas is often temporary and episodic. As such, this paper brings into question the distinctiveness and overall utility of the concept: 'the rural homeless'. The key determinant of negative attitudes to health care may not be recent homelessness. It may be entrenched socio-economic marginalization, and the resultant social stigma, that are shared amongst the rural poor, regardless of their current housing status.

Men’s Mental Health: Beyond Victim-Blaming

“…21 Much research indicates that this can be an alienating experience, contributing to under-utilization, drop-out, and a dysfunctional therapeutic alliance. 22,23 Indeed, the field of women’s mental health has benefited from an approach that studiously avoids victim-blaming; for example, in the treatment of eating disorders. It would be crass and superficial to blame a female patient for the onset of an eating disorder, and it would be considered grossly insensitive to glibly suggest that all she needs to do is ‘eat more’.…”

Clueless: An ethnographic study of young men who participate in the seduction community with a focus on their psychosocial well-being and mental health

“…Of note, the first author has decades of experience as a qualitative researcher, and has successfully conducted numerous mental health oriented qualitative studies, including research with immigrant women [49], African-Americans [50], and the rural homeless [51] This experience gave the author many transferable skills which were used throughout the study. As an experienced qualitative researcher, the first author ensured that the study was based on values that have been identified as essential to the ethical conduct of qualitative research including 'empathy, caring, sharing and understanding' [48].…”

‘Genuine doctor care’: Perspectives on general practice and community‐based care of Australian men experiencing homelessness

“…Feelings of being judged, rejected and labelled are reported to be common (Darbyshire et al, ; Wen et al, ). Healthcare experiences may therefore further traumatise many homeless people (Greenwood & Manning, ; SAMHSA, ), explaining some of their ‘abiding aversion to doctors (and) hospitals’ (Whitley, ).…”