Female Entrepreneurship and the Metanarrative of Economic Growth: A Critical Review of Underlying Assumptions

Abstract

This critical review of the literature on female entrepreneurship problematizes the metanarrative of economic growth and the mechanisms through which it both operates and is maintained. Central to this is the axiomatic ‘underperformance hypothesis’, which states that ‘all else being equal, female entrepreneurs tend to be less successful than their male counterparts in terms of conventional economic performance measures’ (Du Rietz and Henrekson (2000, p. 1). As an axiom, the truth of the ‘underperformance hypothesis’ is taken for granted, and thus it invisibly serves as a starting point, delimiter and interpretive lens for analysis in this field. While it remains invisible, the hypothesis will continue to reproduce the differences between male and female entrepreneurs, and thus the subordination of women to men in the realm of entrepreneurship. The review illustrates how, by associating females with underperformance, the persistent influence of the metanarrative of economic growth has been masked and the image of the female entrepreneur as problematic and inferior to her male counterpart has been reinforced. The authors argue that a postmodern feminist epistemology will destabilize both the metanarrative of economic growth, and the axiomatic ‘underperformance hypothesis’ it supports, thus opening up space for a heterogeneous understanding of (female) entrepreneurship. By questioning accepted knowledge about female entrepreneurs, the review sets the platform for the exploration of new research questions and a broad agenda for future research. Such an agenda is crucial in order to move future research beyond the pervasive influence of the metanarrative of economic growth and its attendant underperformance hypothesis.

Bad Witches: Gender and the Downfall of Elizabeth Holmes of Theranos and Disney’s Maleficent

“…Because of the similarities between Maleficent (1959) and EH (2019+), the way forward starts with awareness of an unconscious gender bias that is collectively promulgated and then unwittingly internalized and reinforced by individuals exposed to fictional and non-fictional narratives alike. As Microsoft founder and STEM magnate Bill Gates warns, the Theranos scandal might become "an excuse to write off" women who break boundaries (Gates 2018, para 11), especially given the propensity to ignore the successes of female entrepreneurs (Dean et al 2019). We must think critically about stories that demonize powerful women whose progress is perceived as being at males' expense.…”

An Investigation of the Role of Female Entrepreneurship in The Economic Development of Saudi Arabia

“…In fact, from the year 2001-2010 approximately 1.5 million gulf countries women in GCC joined as a labour force (Pinkovetskaia et al, 2019). Therefore, it can be stated that female entrepreneurship is one of the emerging aspects that helps the nation in the development of its economic condition (Dean et al, 2019). The GCC countries women also have the potentiality to handle the high level of stress in their workplace and that is one of the positive reasons for the development of economic condition in the market of Saudi Arabia.…”

Gender, Credit, and Firm Outcomes

“…In contrast, several studies suggest that such effects are due to external unobserved factors, and that similarities between the sexes are more important than are their differences (Ahl (2006); Dean, Larsen, Ford, and Akram (2019)).…”

“…Recent evidence does not fully back up these propositions (for a recent review, see Dean, Larsen, Ford, and Akram (2019)), however, while the literature identifies such effects to be more pronounced in less developed economies (Asiedu, Kalonda-Kanyama, Ndikumana, and Nti-Addae (2013), Ongena and Popov (2016)).…”