SignificanceBy concatenating the fields of continuum mechanics and alloy thermodynamics in a unified framework, the theory of open system elasticity by Francis Larché and John W. Cahn achieved one of the key advances in thermodynamics of the 20th century. The theory’s implications for the coupling between stress and composition are generally well acknowledged, yet selected issues are under debate. It is, therefore, dissatisfactory that the predictions for the open system elastic parameters—as the theory’s central materials descriptors—await experimental verification. Here, we report that the variation of the open system Young’s modulus of palladium hydride with composition is in excellent agreement with the prediction. This confirms a cornerstone of materials’ theory.