Financial disincentives to formal employment and tax-benefit systems in Latin America

Abstract

The aim of this paper is twofold. First, it provides a comprehensive assessment of the financial disincentives to enter formal employment implied by the design of the tax-benefit system in five Latin American countries: Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, and Venezuela. Then, it analyzes the extent to which formalizing informal workers would contribute to increase fiscal capacity in the region. The results show a wide variation in financial disincentives to enter formal employment, with formalization tax rates ranging between 8.5 percent in Venezuela and 42 percent in Colombia. Formalization tax rates are particularly high for self-employed informal workers, and mainly driven by the high costs associated with social insurance contributions. The analysis further shows that potential entries to formal employment would raise tax revenue in all countries, but mainly through the effect of increased social insurance contributions, whereas personal income tax revenue would have a marginal contribution, except in Bolivia and Venezuela. Interestingly, potential formalization of informal workers with the highest probability of being formal would allow capturing a substantial share of the additional tax revenue lost due to informality.

Assessing the Effect of Fiscal Policies on the Gender Income Gap in Central America, Panama and the Dominican Republic

“…Finally, income taxes affect only the top of the distribution (last three deciles) and even in the case of Costa Rica, the most redistributive country, they represent only 5% of disposable income for the last decile. The limited incidence of income taxes is also a feature of other Latin American countries and is related to the high exempted tax thresholds and the presence of generous deductions (Jara et al 2023). We find that, in every country and in every income quintile, disposable income for women is lower than for men.…”

“…It was originally designed for the countries of the European Union and is financed by the European Commission. More recently, the EUROMOD platform has been used to create tax-benefit models for several Latin American countries (seeJara et al 2023, Dondo et al 2024). 5 Some components of certain cash transfer programs could not be simulated due to the lack of information in the data to model eligibility.…”

The effect of fiscal drag on income distribution and work incentives: A microsimulation analysis on selected African countries

“…Increasing METRs would imply a disincentive for individuals to exert more effort in formal employment, potentially prompting them to quit or transition to informal occupations. In the same perspective, Jara et al (2023) explores the financial disincentives to formal employment in selected Latin American countries showing that the reduction in earnings due to transitioning from informal to formal occupations – from 8.5% in Venezuela to 42% in Colombia – is driven to a great extent by the structure of the tax‐benefit system.…”

Benefits of the Special Tax Regime Special Economic and Social Zone versus the Ordinary Income Tax Regime: An empirical study

“…(2) En países como Colombia, Chile o Perú se utiliza el impuesto de renta como uno de los principales mecanismos de recaudo, aunque en el caso colombiano la reglamentación se encuentra más dispersa en diferentes disposiciones del Estatuto Tributario que suelen ser confusas y repetitivas. (3) No obstante, el impuesto sobre la renta ha tenido diferentes tratamientos preferenciales mediante deducciones, exenciones, descuentos y disposiciones normativas especiales, para alcanzar objetivos sociales, como puede ser la generación de empleo, la reactivación económica o la inversión. (4) Pero estudios realizados sobre el tema demuestran que es necesario analizar el impacto de cualquier beneficio tributario para confirmar que se logra la finalidad perseguida y que es beneficioso para los contribuyentes.…”