Research on African women often emphasizes their traditional roles as water fetchers and caregivers, but their potential role in water governance is frequently overlooked. Here, this research gap is explored with a focus on the sustainability of water access points (WAPs). The latest mWater tool version 3.0. was used to conduct household surveys concerning gender roles in water access in rural Mbala of northern Zambia. Purposive sampling, a non-probability methodological approach, was used to choose respondents. The Empowerment in water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) Index (EWI) was adopted to quantify empowerment levels. The analysis revealed significant contributors to disempowerment, such as group membership, control over household goods, work balance, and leadership in WAP implementation. The study also highlighted the critical role of Water Point Committees (WPCs) in sustaining WAPs. An unexpected finding emerges as the data contests the prevalent notion that women, who are primarily responsible for water fetching, are marginalized from decision-making processes. Instead, the results suggest that women's disempowerment is not the primary factor contributing to the lack of sustainability of WAPs. Rather, a general lack of financial commitment within communities is at play. The study highlights the critical, yet previously overlooked, role of community meetings in ensuring the sustainability of WAPs.