Financialization without liquidity: in‐kind payments, forced credit, and authoritarianism at the periphery of Europe

Abstract

After 2008, the spectacular collapse of financial markets in the United States, Spain, Iceland, Portugal, and Greece has induced researchers to conceptualize financialization as a rapid and unsustainable increase in liquidity. In Macedonia, a small country at the periphery of the European Union, however, the spread of financial instruments and debt coincided with an increased use of in‐kind payments instead of money. Focusing on a type of non‐monetary exchanges that Macedonians call kompenzacija, the article shows how in‐kind payments are integrated to financial flows, and are crucial to the emergence of an authoritarian regime. In the Macedonian context, kompenzacija is part of an oppressive set of relations whereby companies are forced to provide monetary credit to the regime by accepting payment in goods that lose value over time. The article describes the conditions that shape financialization at the periphery of Europe, and identifies in value conversions a crucial variable for understanding the interconnection between politics and finance.

How Subordinate Financialization Shapes Urban Development: The Rise and Fall of Warsaw's Służewiec Business District

“…In Poland this means considering the country's transformations from state socialism to market capitalism. With the exception of a number of studies on housing financialization in the former German Democratic Republic (Fields and Uffer, ; Bernt et al , ; Wijburg and Aalbers, ) and single studies on Hungary (Pósfai et al , ) and Macedonia (Mattioli, ), few works examine real estate financialization in post‐socialist Europe. This not only implies a lack of scholarly attention to the rapid growth in mortgage lending and inflow of financial capital to these countries’ real estate markets in recent years (Bohle, ; Pósfai et al , ); it also means that there has been little conceptual work exploring how transformation and post‐socialism relate to dynamics of real estate financialization and financialization more generally.…”

Money

“…These practices of so-called 'low finance' can be unexpectedly transnational. (Mattioli 2018). At the same time, Wall Street stockbrokers, driven by a belief in maximising shareholder value, justify business practices that destabilised markets, companies, and jobs (Ho 2009).…”

European social anthropology in 2018: an increasingly recursive public

“…As Weiss observes, 'the boundary between workers and capitalists is increasingly porous ' (2018: 113). Indeed, a range of recent scholarship, especially research exploring brokerage (Chalhi, Koster and Vermeulen 2018;James 2018;Lindquist 2018;Koster and van Leynseele 2018), points to a generalised retreat of straightforward labour relations as a means of organising social life (see also Mattioli 2018). For instance, Dolan and Rajak (2018) identify renewed interest in global development circles in promoting 'entrepreneurship' among the underemployed at the 'bottom of the pyramid' -which only seems like a short step from another phenomenon on the rise: pyramid schemes (Schiffauer 2018a(Schiffauer , 2018b.…”