Find the Hidden Object. Understanding Play in Psychological Assessments

Abstract

Standardized psychological assessments are extensively used by practitioners to determine rate and level of development in different domains of ability in both typical and atypical children. The younger the children, the more likely the trials will resemble play activities. However, mode of administration, timing and use of objects involved are constrained. The purpose of this study is to explore what kind of play is play in psychological assessments, what are the expectations about children's performance and what are the abilities supporting the test activities. Conversation Analysis (CA) was applied to the videorecording of an interaction between a child and a practitioner during the administration of the Bayley Scale of Infant and Toddler Development, III edition. The analysis focuses on a 2′07″ long sequence relative to the administration of the test item “Find the hidden object” to a 23 months old child with Down syndrome. The analysis of the sequence shows that the assessor promotes the child's engagement by couching the actions required to administer the item in utterances with marked child-directed features. The analysis also shows that the objects constituting the test item did not suggest to the child a unique course of action, leading to the assessor's modeling of the successful sequence. We argue that when a play frame is activated by an interactional partner, the relational aspect of the activity is foregrounded and the co-player becomes a source of cues for ways in which playing can develop. We discuss the assessment interaction as orienting the child toward a right-or-wrong interpretation, leaving the realm of play, which is inherently exploratory and inventive, to enter that of instructional activities. Finally, we argue that the sequential analysis of the interaction and of the mutual sense-making procedures that partners put in place during the administration of an assessment could be used in the design and evaluation of tests for a finer understanding of the abilities involved.

Association Between Preschoolers’ Specific Fine (But Not Gross) Motor Skills and Later Academic Competencies: Educational Implications

“…Play is an essential methodological tool of ECE and it should not be separated from a child's life. Therefore, it is an indispensable tool for the teaching-learning process of children and the observation and analysis of their progress and development (Fasulo et al, 2017;Salcuni et al, 2017;Zosh et al, 2018). But in addition, when play is framed within a world of fantasy, children's intrinsic motivation, and engagement increase (Garris et al, 2002;Paley, 2005).…”

Improvement of Planning Skills in Children With Autism Spectrum Disorder After an Educational Intervention: A Study From a Mixed Methods Approach

“…Playing is a child's natural way of expression and provides opportunities for his/ her development and learning. This makes games an essential tool for children's teaching-learning process and for the systematic observation and analysis of their progress (Fasulo et al, 2017;Otsuka and Jay, 2017;Zosh et al, 2018). However, despite its importance, there are few works that carry out a valid and reliable child intervention and evaluation based on games (Salcuni et al, 2017;Hillman, 2018).…”

Systematic Observation: Relevance of This Approach in Preschool Executive Function Assessment and Association with Later Academic Skills

“…The recent literature on early childhood education and development increasingly argues that the assessment of development processes and learning during preschool should be done primarily through systematic observation in the natural learning context ( Early Head Start National Resource Center, 2013 ; Jablon et al, 2013 ). The literature also stresses that play—an activity inseparable from a child’s life—is an indispensable resource for the childhood teaching–learning process and for the systematic observation of children’s progress and development ( Nell and Drew, 2013 ; Fasulo et al, 2017 ). Systematic observation of a child’s behavior during play makes it possible to obtain relevant data to describe, explain, and understand fundamental aspects of the child’s development and learning ( Federici et al, 2017 ; Otsuka and Jay, 2017 ), including the development of EFs.…”