Fine wine or sour grapes? A systematic review and meta-analysis of the impact of red wine polyphenols on vascular health

Abstract

Purpose Red wine polyphenols (RWP) are plant-based molecules that have been extensively studied in relation to their protective effects on vascular health in both animals and humans. The aim of this review was to quantify and compare the efficacy of RWP and pure resveratrol on outcomes measures of vascular health and function in both animals and humans. Methods Comprehensive database searches were carried out through PubMed, Web of Science and OVID for randomised, placebo-controlled studies in both animals and humans. Meta-analyses were carried out on acute and chronic studies of RWP in humans, alongside subgroup analysis where possible. Risk-of-bias assessment was carried out for all included studies based on randomisation, allocation, blinding, outcome data reporting, and other biases. Results 48 animal and 37 human studies were included in data extraction following screening. Significant improvements in measures of blood pressure and vascular function following RWP were seen in 84% and 100% of animal studies, respectively. Human studies indicated significant improvements in systolic blood pressure overall (− 2.6 mmHg, 95% CI: [− 4.8, − 0.4]), with a greater improvement in pure-resveratrol studies alone (− 3.7 mmHg, 95% CI: [− 7.3, − 0.0]). No significant effects of RWP were seen in diastolic blood pressure or flow-mediated dilation (FMD) of the brachial artery. Conclusion RWP have the potential to improve vascular health in at risk human populations, particularly in regard to lowering systolic blood pressure; however, such benefits are not as prevalent as those observed in animal models.

Wine Intake in the Framework of a Mediterranean Diet and Chronic Non-Communicable Diseases: A Short Literature Review of the Last 5 Years

“…No significant effects were found for DBP (−1.0 mmHg, 95% CI −2.2 to 0.3; p = 0.139). The authors suggested that the non-significant effect on DBP could be attributed to the small changes seen in DBP in clinical hypertension [109]. Nonetheless, these findings are consistent with previous studies on resveratrol [95].…”

Review on the Regional Effects of Gastrointestinal Luminal Stimulation on Appetite and Energy Intake: (Pre)clinical Observations

“…In these studies, the hypothesis was tested that post-oral delivery of non-caloric tastants will result in a net decreased energy intake compared with placebo. Klaassen et al recently published a systematic review and meta-analysis on this topic [ 63 ]. These authors report on the effects of gastrointestinal administration of tastants on eating behavior.…”

Wine’s Phenolic Compounds and Health: A Pythagorean View

“…Finally, animal studies often employ very high doses of grape (poly)phenols, e.g., resveratrol and their results cannot be readily transferred to humans, who would need to ingest several grams of extracts to replicate the same effects. Indeed, a discrepancy between animal and human effects has just been underscored [ 5 ] and resveratrol’s potential toxicity has been recently reviewed [ 67 ]. An often overlooked paper reported that resveratrol promoted atherosclerotic development in hypercholesterolemic rabbits, by a mechanism that is independent of observed differences in gross animal health, liver function, plasma cholesterol concentrations, or LDL oxidative status [ 68 ].…”

“…The debate on alcohol use and health is becoming heavily polarized: one party underscores a large amount of data in support of the J curve [ 1 , 3 ] whereas the other side dismisses such evidence and calls for total abstention [ 2 , 3 ]. In support of the former, researchers and the lay press often advocate the health benefits of (poly)phenol consumption via red wine intake and cite the vast amount of in vitro literature that would corroborate the hypothesis [ 4 , 5 ].…”