Fire Sales in a Model of Complexity

Abstract

Financial assets provide return and liquidity services to their holders. However, during severe financial crises many asset prices plummet, destroying their liquidity provision function at the worst possible time. In this paper we present a model of fire sales and market breakdowns, and of the financial amplification mechanism that follows from them. The distinctive feature of our model is the central role played by endogenous complexity: As asset prices implode, more "banks" within the financial network become distressed, which increases each (non-distressed) bank's likelihood of being hit by an indirect shock. As this happens, banks face an increasingly complex environment since they need to understand more and more interlinkages in making their financial decisions. This complexity brings about confusion and uncertainty, which makes relatively healthy banks, and hence potential asset buyers, reluctant to buy since they now fear becoming embroiled in a cascade they do not control or understand. The liquidity of the market quickly vanishes and a financial crisis ensues. The model exhibits a powerful "complexity-externality." As a potential asset buyer chooses to pull back, the size of the cascade grows, which increases the degree of complexity of the environment. This rise in perceived complexity induces other healthy banks to pull back, which exacerbates the fire sale and the cascade. JEL Codes: E0, Gl, D8, E5

Measuring the Behavioural Component of the S&P 500 and its Relationship to Financial Stress and Aggregated Earnings Surprises

“…Finally, our results complement the financial literature claiming that crises are seen as periods of increased ambiguity of future asset returns (Bernanke, ; Caballero and Simsek, ; Vinogradov, ), which in turn provides an additional explanation of the rise in the behavioural component periods of economic and financial turbulences.…”

Recovery from the Asian financial crisis: the importance of non‐monetary financial factors

“…While Friedman and Schwartz () spearhead a large literature highlighting the role that the money supply plays in economic performance, Bernanke () and the many other studies cited in the previous section suggest that non‐monetary financial variables can also play a major role. Closely related to our work here, Diamond and Rajan (), Hummel (), and Caballero and Simsek () argue that non‐monetary financial factors can deepen economic crises or slow recovery from them. Such factors include bank profitability, bank liquidity, and non‐performing loans.…”

(In)Efficient Interbank Networks

“…A related fast‐growing literature studies the propagation of negative shocks in financial networks. Contrary to our approach, this literature takes the structure of the network as given (Caballero and Simsek , Elliott, Golub, and Jackson , Acemoglu, Ozdaglar, and Tahbaz‐Salehi , Castiglionesi and Eboli ). A different approach is taken by Acemoglu, Ozdaglar, and Tahbaz‐Salehi () and Zawadowsky () who analyze the strategic link formation among banks located however on a given network shaped as a ring.…”