“…Figure 1 shows this as a function of latitude and solar longitude for the two simulations (MPCO2, top; MPCO2+H2OCN: bottom). The figure includes also a comparison to mesospheric CO 2 ice cloud observations (black dots) from several instruments (Clancy et al, 2007;Montmessin et al, 2006Montmessin et al, , 2007Määttänen et al, 2010;McConnochie et al, 2010;Scholten et al, 2010;Vincendon et al, 2011;Aoki et al, 2018;Clancy et al, 2019;Jiang et al, 2019;Liuzzi et al, 2021) and to the area of observed CO 2 supersaturation in the polar regions (black solid line) derived from MCS temperature profiles (Hu et al (2012). The two panels in Figure 1 clearly demonstrate that the predicted polar winter cloud distributions are overall very similar in the two simulations, and the largest di erences appear around the equator where the mesospheric clouds form.…”