First-generation and continuing-generation college graduates’ application, acceptance, and matriculation to U.S. medical schools: a national cohort study

Abstract

Many U.S. medical schools conduct holistic review of applicants to enhance the socioeconomic and experiential diversity of the physician workforce. The authors examined the role of first-generation college-graduate status on U.S. medical school application, acceptance, and matriculation, hypothesizing that first-generation (vs. continuing-generation) college graduates would be less likely to apply and gain acceptance to medical school.Secondary analysis of de-identified data from a retrospective national-cohort study was conducted for individuals who completed the 2001–2006 Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) Pre-Medical College Admission Test Questionnaire (PMQ) and the Medical College Admissions Test (MCAT). AAMC provided medical school application, acceptance, and matriculation data through 06/09/2013. Multivariable logistic regression models identified demographic, academic, and experiential variables independently associated with each outcome and differences between first-generation and continuing-generation students. Of 262,813 PMQ respondents, 211,216 (80.4%) MCAT examinees had complete data for analysis and 24.8% self-identified as first-generation college graduates. Of these, 142,847 (67.6%) applied to U.S. MD-degree-granting medical schools, of whom 86,486 (60.5%) were accepted, including 14,708 (17.0%) first-generation graduates; 84,844 (98.1%) acceptees matriculated. Adjusting for all variables, first-generation (vs. continuing-generation) college graduates were less likely to apply (odds ratio [aOR] 0.84; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.82–0.86) and be accepted (aOR 0.86; 95% CI, 0.83–0.88) to medical school; accepted first-generation college graduates were as likely as their continuing-generation peers to matriculate. Students with (vs. without) paid work experience outside hospitals/labs/clinics were less likely to apply, be accepted, and matriculate into medical school. Increased efforts to mitigate structural socioeconomic vulnerabilities that may prevent first-generation college students from applying to medical school are needed. Expanded use of holistic review admissions practices may help decision makers value the strengths first-generation college graduates and other underrepresented applicants bring to medical educationand the physician workforce.

Selection tools and student diversity in health professions education: a multi-site study

“…Applicants were categorized as first-generation university applicants when none of their parents had attended higher education, i.e., university or higher vocational education. First-generation university applicants were a subgroup of interest, because previous research has demonstrated that their odds of being selected into medical school are lower (Mason et al, 2021 ; Stegers-Jager et al, 2015 ). Additionally, they face numerous obstacles when applying to medical school, including a lack of knowledge about the admission process and financial barriers (Romero et al, 2020 ).…”

Revolutionizing Health Professions Admissions to Achieve an Inclusive Workforce

“…10 To diversify the physician workforce, admissions committees should consider making the MCAT optional or pass-fail, and placing greater emphasis on other criteria. 11 Schools using holistic review are more likely to examine other non-academic criteria such as socioeconomic status, 12 experience working with disadvantaged populations, and mission alignment (eg, focus on underserved rural or urban communities). 13,14 Some physician assistant programs examine measures of humanistic and collaborative skills including applicants' experience as patient educators, community organizers, or working at community-based organizations.…”

Opinion & Special Articles: Examining the Hidden Curriculum of Medical School From a First-Generation Student Perspective

“…5 To date, most research has centered on FGLI undergraduates, with little data pertaining to graduate students. 6 Medical schools have outlines for the competencies and knowledge they expect students to garner. However, there are other skills that must be cultivated to utilize the full resources of medical school and position oneself for residency.…”