Nongeographic and geographic variation have been analyzed in the genus Brachyphylla , which belongs to the Antillean endemic subfamily Phyllonycterinae of the family Phyllostomatidae. Males were found to be generally larger than females; therefore, the sexes were analyzed separately for geographic variation. External measurements except length of forearm were found to display a high degree of individual variation. They were not used in subsequent analyses. Of cranial measurements, greatest length of skull and condylobasal length showed the least individual variation, whereas palatal length, postorbital breadth (in samples from west of the Mona Passage only), and rostral width at canines showed relatively high coefficients of variation. Variation in color was found not to follow any geographic pattern.Two species -Brachyphylla cavernanim and B. nana -were recognized in the genus. B. cavernanim occurs on Puerto Rico, the Virgin Islands, and the Lesser Antilles as far south as St. Vincent. Three subspecies are recognized. Populations of large bats occur on St. Croix in the Virgin Islands and the Lesser Antilles as far south as St. Vincent. The smallest individuals occur only on the island of Barbados. Populations of bats of intermediate size, described herein as a new subspecies, occur on Puerto Rico and most of the Virgin Islands. Brachyphylla nana is a monotypic species occurring on Cuba, Isle of Pines, Grand Cayman, Middle Caicos, and Hispaniola and as a sub-Recent fossil on Jamaica.