Fit, Female or Fifty–Is Cardiac Rehabilitation “Fit” for Purpose for All? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis With Meta-Regression

Abstract

AimsCardiac rehabilitation (CR) is an evidence-based intervention promoting risk factor modification following coronary artery disease events but the relative benefits for patient subgroups is not clear. This review synthesizes the available evidence on the effectiveness of modern CR programs and determines outcomes for age, sex and prior level of fitness.MethodsMEDLINE, CINAHL, and EMBASE were examined for RCT and cohort studies involving exercise prescription or phase II or III CR following Myocardial Infarction (MI), Percutaneous Coronary Intervention (PCI) and cardiac surgery from January 2010 to February 2021. Outcomes assessed included peakVO2max, 6-min walk test and Metabolic Equivalent of Task. Meta-regression was used to determine CR impact for change in fitness and age and sex influences.ResultsThe mean age of study participants was 59.5 years and 82.7% were male. Females, younger people and those of average or above cardiorespiratory fitness were substantially under-represented in data and attendance, with 13% of study groups with a mean age <55 years. At entry, 73% were below average for fitness vs. age-matched normative values. Fitness improved across all groups following CR with no evidence of sex or age independently affecting outcomes.ConclusionsModest improvements in fitness in all groups were shown, but the benefits of CR can be far greater. A modern, innovative approach to CR will likely lead to more substantial benefits. This may require a “Precision Medicine” model which tailors exercise prescription to different populations to ensure all CR participant's needs are met. This will ensure that CR is more flexible and accessible for all.

Skeletal Muscle MicroRNA Patterns in Response to a Single Bout of Exercise in Females: Biomarkers for Subsequent Training Adaptation?

“…Moreover, exercise protocols are highly heterogeneous, ranging from single bouts to training of several months’ duration. Finally, subjects’ characteristics are diverse, and, as in most areas of exercise biology, females are underrepresented in the relevant studies [ 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 ].…”

Home-based cardiac rehabilitation: development, implementation and outcome evaluation in patients with coronary artery diseases in Lahore, Pakistan – a mixed-methods study protocol

“…To make their behaviours change, CR as part of secondary prevention is an utmost strategy for those who experienced a cardiac event or underwent any other cardiac procedure to get back to their activities of daily living. Therefore, CR is one of the best strategies to bring the increasing number of cases down 9. CR possesses strategies for secondary prevention that allow cardiac patient to rebuild their capacity and reduce the number of hospital visits.…”