Fitting Characteristics of N95 Filtering-Facepiece Respirators Used Widely in China

Abstract

BackgroundMillions of people rely on N95 filtering facepiece respirators to reduce the risk of airborne particles and prevent them from respiratory infections. However, there are no respirator fit testing and training regulations in China. Meanwhile, no study has been conducted to investigate the fit of various respirators. The objective of this study was to investigate whether people obtained adequate fit when wearing N95 filtering facepiece respirators (FFRs) used widely in China.MethodsFifty adult participants selected using the Chinese respirator fit test panel donned 10 common models of N95 FFRs. Fit factors (FF) and inward leakage were measured using the TSI PortaCount Plus. Each subject was tested with three replications for each model. A subject was considered to pass the fit test when at least two of the three FFs were greater than 100. Two models were conducted fit tests before and after training to assess the role of training.ResultsThe geometric mean FFs for each model and trained subjects ranged from <10 to 74.0. The fifth percentile FFs for only two individual respirator models were greater than 10 which is the expected level of performance for FFRs. The passing rates for these two models of FFRs were 44.7% and 20.0%. The passing rates were less than 10.0% for the other eight models. There were 27 (54%) participants who passed none of the 10 FFRs. The geometric mean FFs for both models when the subjects received training (49.7 and 74.0) were significantly larger than those when the same group of subjects did not receive any training (29.0 and 30.9) (P<0.05).ConclusionsFFRs used widely in China should be improved according to Chinese facial dimensions. Respirator users could benefit from respirator training and fit testing before using respirators.

Ethanol-Drying Regeneration of N95 Respirators

“…This is unfortunate because studies have shown that the leakage around the mask, not through the medium, is the main determinant of total mask efficiency 18 . Poor fit can reduce an N95 mask from 95% to below 60% efficiency, which is below that of some masks made from commercial fabric 19,20 . In contrast, our testing setup uses a head model, upon which the mask is "worn", and is remarkably quick and easy to seal completely against the plastic film wrapped around the head model.…”

Implementation of tuberculosis infection control measures in designated hospitals in Zhejiang Province, China: are we doing enough to prevent nosocomial tuberculosis infections?

“… 32 However, most of the respirators sold in China are designed according to specifications set by a panel of the US Los Alamos National Laboratory, which are based on facial features more typical of adults in Western countries. 33 Compared with the Western population, Asian populations have higher failure rates in fit testing for respirators of the same size. 34 In our study, although the use of N95 respirators among HCWs was better than that reported in previous studies, 10 12 13 only 50% of designated hospitals conducted fit-testing for respirators.…”

Variations in Head-and-Face Shape of Chinese Civilian Workers

“…The fit of widely used N95 filtering facepiece respirators in China are poor because respirator manufacturers currently design their respirators in accordance with Los Alamos Laboratory fit test panels (Yu et al , 2014). The need for representative head-and-face shapes in China is great.…”