Five teacher profiles in student-centred curricula based on their conceptions of learning and teaching

Abstract

BackgroundTeachers’ conceptions of learning and teaching are partly unconscious. However, they are critical for the delivery of education and affect students’ learning outcomes. Lasting changes in teaching behaviour can only be realized if conceptions of teachers have been changed accordingly. Previously we constructed a questionnaire named COLT to measure conceptions. In the present study, we investigated if different teacher profiles could be assessed which are based on the teachers’ conceptions. These teacher profiles might have implications for individual teachers, for faculty development activities and for institutes. Our research questions were: (1) Can we identify teacher profiles based on the COLT? (2) If so, how are these teacher profiles associated with other teacher characteristics?MethodsThe COLT questionnaire was sent electronically to all teachers in the first three years of the undergraduate curriculum of Medicine in two medical schools in the Netherlands with student-centred education. The COLT (18 items, 5 point Likert scales) comprises three scales: ‘teacher centredness’, ‘appreciation of active learning’ and ‘orientation to professional practice’. We also collected personal information about the participants and their occupational characteristics. Teacher profiles were studied using a K-means cluster analysis and calculating Chi squares.ResultsThe response rate was 49.4% (N = 319/646). A five-cluster solution fitted the data best, resulting in five teacher profiles based on their conceptions as measured by the COLT. We named the teacher profiles: Transmitters (most traditional), Organizers, Intermediates, Facilitators and Conceptual Change Agents (most modern). The teacher profiles differed from each other in personal and occupational characteristics.ConclusionsBased on teachers’ conceptions of learning and teaching, five teacher profiles were found in student-centred education. We offered suggestions how insight into these teacher profiles might be useful for individual teachers, for faculty development activities and for institutes and departments, especially if involved in a curriculum reform towards student-centred education.

Conceptions of learning factors in postgraduate health sciences master students: a comparative study with non-health science students and between genders

“…These achievements can be predicted based on the type of strategy they have previously designed [ 11 , 14 , 15 ]. Recently, several studies have demonstrated that teachers’ conceptions of learning also affect, although indirectly, students’ learning outcomes [ 16 – 18 ].…”

Teachers’ conceptions of learning and teaching in student-centred medical curricula: the impact of context and personal characteristics

“…In an earlier study, we used the COLT questionnaire to measure teachers’ conceptions of learning and teaching in two student-centered medical curricula [ 8 ]. A cluster analysis resulted in five teacher profiles, ranging from a traditional profile aiming to transmit knowledge to a more modern profile aligned with student-centered education [ 9 ].…”

Reforms in VUmc School of Medical Sciences Amsterdam: Student engagement, a Minor elective semester and stakeholder collaboration in improving the quality of assessments

“…It took even more time for faculty to adjust to the small group teaching concept. In our research, we found that the perception of teaching and learning of faculty was still more teacher-centered than student-centered, even after 10 years of curricular change to small group teaching (Jacobs et al 2014). The second important lesson we learned is that it is important for a medical school to refresh its vision from time to time and align to the changing societal context, e.g.…”