Other than acute coronary syndrome (ACS), many clinical conditions are associated with increased cardiac troponin I (cTnI) levels. Conditions such as pulmonary embolism, acute heart failure, myocarditis, sepsis, and renal failure are commonly reported as underlying causes. Analytical interference with the cTnI assay can also lead to falsely elevated troponin I levels. That can happen due to multiple causes such as fibrin clots, heterophile antibodies, microparticles contained in the sample, rheumatoid factor, interference by bilirubin, hemolysis, and elevated alkaline phosphatase activity. Herein, we present the case of a 66-yearold female who presented with pleuritic chest pain and had a cTnI of 35.5 ng/mL post-transfusion of three units of packed red blood cells. The patient had a complete ischemic workup for ACS, including coronary angiography, which was negative for coronary artery disease.