The method of collision-induced dissociation threshold analysis
for determining carbene thermochemistry
is applied to the ground-state triplet carbenes CH2
(methylene, 1), CH2CHCH (vinylcarbene,
2), and PhCH
(phenylcarbene, 3). The chief aims of this study are to
evaluate the energetic and dynamical consequences of the
obligatory curve-crossing that characterizes dissociation of a halide
ion from an α-halocarbanion to form a carbene
with a triplet ground state, and to determine accurate heats of
formation for 2 and 3. Threshold collision
energies
for loss of halide from CH2X- (X = Cl, Br),
CH2CHCHX- (X = Cl, Br, I), and
PhCHX- (X = Cl, Br, I) are
determined with use of a flowing afterglow−triple quadrupole
apparatus. The dissociation energies are combined
with the measured gas-phase acidities of the corresponding methyl,
allyl, and benzyl halides in simple thermochemical
cycles in order to derive the absolute heats of formation for the
carbenes. The value of
ΔH
f,298(1) derived from
the
results for the two different methyl halides (92.2 ± 3.7 kcal/mol) is
in excellent agreement with the well-established
literature value for the triplet ground state of methylene:
ΔH
f,298[X̃
3B1 CH2] = 92.9 ± 0.6
kcal/mol. The good
agreement indicates that dissociation of the halomethyl anions occurs
adiabatically to produce the triplet state of the
product without any significant reverse activation energy or dynamical
constraints. The measured dissociation energies
for 1-chloro-, 1-bromo-, and 1-iodoallyl anions are combined with the
bracketed acidities of allyl chloride, bromide,
and iodide to yield three independently determined but closely matched
values for ΔH
f,298(2): 92.3
± 2.6, 93.9 ±
3.4, and 93.2 ± 3.1 kcal/mol, respectively. The average value
from the three determinations, 93.3 ± 3.4 kcal/mol,
is in fair agreement with the estimated heat of formation for the
triplet ground state of 2 obtained from various
MCSCF and density functional calculations (90 kcal/mol), but much lower
than the predicted heat of formation for
the lowest singlet state of 2 (100 kcal/mol). As with
the halomethyl ions, efficient adiabatic dissociation of
the
haloallyl anions at the thermodynamic limit is indicated by these
results. The apparent heats of formation for
3
derived from the measured dissociation energies for
PhCHCl-, PhCHBr- and PhCHI-,
and the bracketed acidities
of the corresponding benzyl halides show a somewhat larger
(non-systematic) variation, but are all within the
assigned
uncertainties. The derived values for
ΔH
f,298(3) are 103.2 ± 3.2,
105.5 ± 2.7, and 100.9 ± 2.8 kcal/mol for the
benzyl chloride, bromide, and iodide systems, respectively, giving an
average value of 102.8 ± 3.5 kcal/mol. The
measured heats of formation for 2 and 3 are
compared with the predictions obtained from various levels of ab
initio
theory. Density functional calculations with the BVWN5 and B3LYP
functionals in conjunction with polarized,
triple-ζ basis sets are found to perform best with respect to the
singlet−triplet splittings and absolute heats o...