The Annual General Meetings (AGMs) of Australian Football Clubs in the 1890s were a community event. These AGMs fulfilled the role of accountability, and the dissemination of financial and non-financial information, and were intertwined with a theatrical function. The theatrical aspects of the meeting which included the stage, enthusiastic participants, eminent dignitaries, cheering, applause and audience engagement meant AGMs were also an exercise in entertainment. Through the narratives of newspapers, this article sheds new light on the interrelationships between the accountability and social roles of the AGM.