For better response to clinical trials under public health emergency: a descriptive analysis COVID-19, SARS, MERS and Ebola intervention clinical trials registration

Abstract

BackgroundCOVID-19 is a novel and highly virulent virus, which caused a rapid and massive onset of clinical trials in a short period of time.With the aim to obtain suggestions in the guidance on performing public health emergency clinical trials, and control this virus in China and other countries and for the prevention of the onset of other infectious viruses in the future. Methods COVID-19, SARS, MERS and Ebola clinical trials registered in the Chinese clinical trial registry and clinical trials.gov were collected and analyzed and intervention protocols were descriptively analyzed, focusing on the analysis and comparison of the drug used. The search period ended on February 24, 2020.ResultsThe number of the registered COVID-19 clinical trials was 295. Among 203 intervention trials, 78.3% (159) were drug clinical trials. The 159 COVID-19 trials were designed and analyzed with the highest proportion of random, open control study [66.0% (105)], and blind randomized trials [13.8% (22)]. The drug mostly used was Lopinavir/Ritonavir (15.1%). The sample size median 100,IQR(interquartile range) 140. The number of the registered SARS was 6, MERS 15, and Ebola 97. Among 3 MERS and 19 Ebola drug intervention clinical trials, MERS and Ebola were randomized, blind, and placebo-controlled drug clinical trials accounting for 100% (3) and 31.6% (6), respectively, while SARS were vaccine trials, without drug intervention clinical trials registered.Conclusions Some of the COVID-19 clinical trials and drug selection performed are somewhat disordered, requiring greater attention to the needs, science assumptions, ethics and quality management of the clinical research. Thus, during the epidemic period, the country should deliver guidance on how to perform appropriate emergency clinical trials, design a scientifically based clinical trial program and focus on researching drugs or vaccines that have great potential.