Force production during the sustained phase of Rugby scrums: a systematic literature review

Abstract

Background: Since World Rugby changed the laws regarding scrums in the 2013-2014 season, the sustained push phase of the scrum has increased in tactical importance. Therefore, the purpose of this systematic literature review was to examine the biomechanical demands during the sustained push phase of individual, unit, and full pack scrummaging. Methods: Pubmed, EBSCO (specifically and simultaneously searching Academic Search Premier, CINAHL, and SPORTDiscus), and Google Scholar were searched for any research that presented force production in a live or simulated rugby scrum. Study quality was appraised using the National Institute of Health's Quality Assessment Tool for Observational Cohort and Cross-Sectional Studies. Recorded scrum forces, positioning of players including joint angles, and testing procedures were extracted and narratively synthesized. Results: Twenty six studies were included in the review. 50% of included studies were rated good, 31% fair, and 19% poor. Major limitations included not reporting any effect size, statistical power, or reliability. Reported group mean values for average sustained forces against a machine generally ranged from 1000 to 2000 N in individual scrums and 4000-8000 N for full packs of male rugby players older than high school age. Individuals seem to optimize their force generation when their shoulders are set against scrum machine pads at approximately 40% of body height, with feet parallel, and with knee and hip angles around 120°. A 10% difference in pack force seems to be necessary for one pack to drive another back in the scrum, but little data exist to quantify differences in force production between winning and losing packs during live scrums. Data collection within studies was not standardized, making comparisons difficult. There is a lack of data in live scrums, and the current research indicates that machine scrums may not replicate many of the demands of live scrums. There is a lack of data for female rugby players. Conclusions: This review indicates an optimal individual body position for players to strive to achieve during scrummaging, consisting of a low body height (40% of stature) and large extended hip and knee angles (120°e ach).

A Hospital Clinic Experience with Isolated Lateral Meniscal Tears in Sports: A Chart Review on Rugby

“…The angle of the knee joint at the time of scrum push is 130°-155°. A study using 14 cadaver knees has shown that at 150°knee flexion, the contact pressure is the highest near the middle segment of the lateral meniscus (24,25). These findings support the deterioration and injury of the middle segment of the lateral meniscus by the repeated push maneuvers during the scrum.…”

Isometric Mid-Thigh Pull Performance in Rugby Players: A Systematic Literature Review

“…First, very little data exist for female rugby players. These players represent a significant proportion of the overall player base, yet there are few studies that have evaluated female players in any capacity [ 51 ], let alone using the IMTP. In addition, it is clear that the majority of data has been collected in Europe; few data have been collected in other areas of the world in which rugby is both popular and is played at a high level.…”

Catastrophic Sports Injuries

“…During prebind, the front-row players are required to bind opposing players with the head facing the opposing players' shoulders and hip and knee angles at 120°( more vertical position). The prebind position reduces the distance between packs, the speed at impact, and the risk of head-to-head contact 108,109 . Following the scrum rule changes and educational efforts, a marked reduction of catastrophic cervical spine injuries (1.8 to 1.0/100,000 from 2006 to 2013 110 ) was reported [110][111][112][113][114] .…”