Forensic psychiatry, one subspecialty with two ethics? A systematic review

Abstract

BackgroundForensic psychiatry is a particular subspecialty within psychiatry, dedicated in applying psychiatric knowledge and psychiatric training for particular legal purposes. Given that within the scope of forensic psychiatry, a third party usually intervenes in the patient-doctor relationship, an amendment of the traditional ethical principles seems justified.ResultsThus, 47 articles, two book chapters and the guidelines produced by the World Psychiatric Association, the American Association of Psychiatry and the Law, as well as by the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of psychiatrists, were analyzed. The review revealed that the ethics of correctional forensic psychiatry and those of legal forensic psychiatry do not markedly differ from each other, but they are incongruent in terms of implementation.MethodsIn an effort to better understand which ethical principles apply to forensic psychiatry, a chronological review of the literature published from 1950 to 2015 was carried out.ConclusionThe ethics of correctional forensic psychiatry are primarily deontological. The principle of justice translates into the principle of health care equivalence, the principle of beneficence into providing the best possible care to patients, and the principle of respect of autonomy into ensuring confidentiality and informed consent. The ethics of legal forensic psychiatry are rather consequentialist. In this latter setting, the principle of justice is mainly characterized by professionalism, the principle of beneficence by objectivity and impartiality, and the principle of respect of autonomy by informed consent. However, these two distinct fields of forensic psychiatry share in common the principle of non maleficence, defined as the non collaboration of the psychiatrist in any activity leading to inhuman and degrading treatment or to the death penalty.

Forensic psychiatry in Finland: an overview of past, present and future

“…Whether there is a causal link between these phenomena, and what the reasons behind the decline in the number of forensic examinations are, is currently under investigation. As modern challenges emerge, discussions continue between clinicians, service-users, policymakers and medico-legal authorities [35,[61][62][63]. Correspondingly, the search for an increasingly evidence-based forensic service system, including clinical practice and risk assessment standards, through scientific research and international collaboration [64] gives reason for optimism for forensic psychiatry in both Finland and elsewhere.…”

Psychopathy Treatment and the Stigma of Yesterday's Research

“…While the American Psychiatric Association provides a general set of guidelines for the psychiatric profession (i.e. the so-called The Principles of Medical Ethics), some researchers have sought to amend these guidelines with crucial nuances specifically applicable to forensic psychiatry (for an overview, see Austin, Goble, and Kelecevic 2009;Niveau and Welle 2018). 12 For example, Paul Appelbaum (1997Appelbaum ( , 2008 has with his so-called standard position argued that two basic principles in particular define the ethical obligations of forensic psychiatric practitioners:…”

Legal Factors and Psychological Stress of Health Professionals in the Forensic Area: A Systematic Review Protocol

“…The forensic psychiatric hospital is part of the eld of forensic psychiatry, which in its essence is related to the assessment and treatment of people with mental disorders, who present antisocial or violent behavior, through the interface of mental health and law [11], which may include the correctional perspective [12]. In conjunction with the forensic psychiatric hospital are general psychiatric hospitals, psychiatric wards in district general hospitals and prisons with regard to the European continent [11]; and in North and South America there are the Psychiatric Custody and Treatment Hospitals (HCTP) [13], which together constitute the forensic area of mental health, commonly called forensic psychiatry.…”