Forest Policy Scenario Analysis: Sensitivity of Songbird Community to Changes in Forest Cover Amount and Configuration

Abstract

Changes in mature forest cover amount, composition, and configuration can be of significant consequence to wildlife populations. The response of wildlife to forest patterns is of concern to forest managers because it lies at the heart of such competing approaches to forest planning as aggregated vs. dispersed harvest block layouts. In this study, we developed a species assessment framework to evaluate the outcomes of forest management scenarios on biodiversity conservation objectives. Scenarios were assessed in the context of a broad range of forest structures and patterns that would be expected to occur under natural disturbance and succession processes. Spatial habitat models were used to predict the effects of varying degrees of mature forest cover amount, composition, and configuration on habitat occupancy for a set of 13 focal songbird species. We used a spatially explicit harvest scheduling program to model forest management options and simulate future forest conditions resulting from alternative forest management scenarios, and used a process-based fire-simulation model to simulate future forest conditions resulting from natural wildfire disturbance. Spatial pattern signatures were derived for both habitat occupancy and forest conditions, and these were placed in the context of the simulated range of natural variation. Strategic policy analyses were set in the context of current Ontario forest management policies. This included use of sequential time-restricted harvest blocks (created for Woodland caribou (Rangifer tarandus) conservation) and delayed harvest areas (created for American marten (Martes americana atrata) conservation). This approach increased the realism of the analysis, but reduced the generality of interpretations. We found that forest management options that create linear strips of old forest deviate the most from simulated natural patterns, and had the greatest negative effects on habitat occupancy, whereas policy options that specify deferment and timing of harvest for large blocks helped ensure the stable presence of an intact mature forest matrix over time. The management scenario that focused on maintaining compositional targets best supported biodiversity objectives by providing the composition patterns required by the 13 focal species, but this scenario may be improved by adding some broad-scale spatial objectives to better maintain large blocks of interior forest habitat through time.RÉSUMÉ. Les changements dans la configuration, la composition et l'étendue du couvert forestier des forêts matures peuvent avoir des conséquences importantes sur les populations fauniques. La réaction de la faune aux patrons forestiers préoccupe les aménagistes car elle est au coeur d'approches de planification forestière aussi divergentes que l'agglomération et la dispersion des parterres de coupe. Dans cette étude, nous avons développé un cadre d'évaluation des espèces afin de mesurer les effets de différents scénarios d'aménagement forestier sur des objectifs de conservation de la biodiversité. Les ...

Conserving migratory land birds in the New World: Do we know enough?

“…2 and few state agencies have funding for research. Canada supports the majority of populations of many Nearctic-Neotropical migrant songbirds and shorebirds, and has landscape patterns extensive enough to successfully allow for the evaluation of broad-scale questions there (Bayne and Hobson 1997, Hobson and Bayne 2000, Hobson et al 2002, Schmiegelow and Monkkonen 2002, Hannon and Drapeau 2005, Rempel et al 2007). We strongly encourage major evaluation and advocacy for funding priorities focused on breeding and post-breeding North American migrant birds so that we can provide the best science-based conservation possible.…”

Modelling Landscape-level Effects of Reduced Herbicide Use in Two Forests in Northern Ontario

“…Rempel et al (1997) showed that the small, dispersed harvest blocks recommended to produce habitat for moose in northwestern Ontario actually resulted in a lower density of moose than areas with larger harvest blocks, likely because the relatively dense road network needed for small blocks increased hunter access. Roads can also contribute to loss of productive land, the spread of invasive species, and sedimentation in water bodies (OMNR 2010).…”

“…Roads are essential for forest management and also provide access for recreation, but there is concern about potential undesirable effects on wildlife and remote fisheries (e.g., Rempel et al 1997, Kaufman et al 2009, Bowman et al 2010. Rempel et al (1997) showed that the small, dispersed harvest blocks recommended to produce habitat for moose in northwestern Ontario actually resulted in a lower density of moose than areas with larger harvest blocks, likely because the relatively dense road network needed for small blocks increased hunter access.…”

“…Simulations can provide valuable information to both forestry professionals and other forest users (Berninger et al 2009). For example, contrasting scenarios have been used to investigate policy changes for land and water use (Baker et al 2004), wildlife habitat suitability (Brown et al 2007, Rempel et al 2007, and biodiversity values (Doyon andDuinker 2003, Van Damme et al 2003).…”

An Estimate of Nest Loss in Canada Due to Industrial Forestry Operations

“…A dominant source of anthropogenic disturbance in Canada's forests is harvesting for pulp, paper, and timber production. How birds respond to forestry activities has generally focused on numerical and demographic changes caused by the effects that forestry has on the composition Bayne 2000, Cavard et al 2011), structure (Schieck and Hobson 2000), and spatial pattern of forests (Rempel et al 2007, Van Wilgenburg and Hobson 2008, Villard et al 2012) at varying times since harvest Schieck 1999, Schieck andSong 2006). These legacy effects are an important conservation issue for many bird species Song 2006, Cumming et al 2010).…”