In this study, the thermodynamic properties and dynamic behavior of ice and hydrate crystal growth in the freezing desalination process were studied. Carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) and 1,1,1,2-tetrafluoroethane (HFC134a) were chosen for this study from various hydrate formers reported in our previous study. A novel approach for calculating the water conversion to ice using the volume change of a gas phase in a reactor was proposed. Under the same subcooling condition, ice and hydrate crystal growth experiments were conducted and compared in pure water and 3.5 wt % NaCl solution. With the experimental conditions of this work, the crystal growth rate results were as follows: In the pure water system, ice crystal > HFC134a hydrate > CO 2 hydrate. However, in the presence of 3.5 wt % NaCl, the order changed as follows: HFC134a hydrate > ice crystal > CO 2 hydrate. These results were consistent with the visual morphology observations and in situ Raman analysis. The variations of subcooling temperature and NaCl concentration were studied using the Hu-Lee-Sum correlation and freezing point depression equation to evaluate the desalination efficiency of freeze desalination. Based on the Raman spectral analysis, we could identify specific hydrate structures and distinguish between ice and hydrate crystals. In situ Raman analysis revealed that dynamic O−H band spectral trends of ice and CO 2 hydrates (structure I) are similar and contrasting with those of the HFC134a hydrate (structure II). These results were first observed during the crystal formation process and can be useful in the design of freezing processes in industrial applications.