The prevailing paradigm in aquatic science is that microbial methanogenesis happens primarily in anoxic environments. Here, we used multiple complementary approaches to show that microbial methane production could and did occur in the well-oxygenated water column of an oligotrophic lake (Lake Stechlin, Germany). Oversaturation of methane was repeatedly recorded in the well-oxygenated upper 10 m of the water column, and the methane maxima coincided with oxygen oversaturation at 6 m. Laboratory incubations of unamended epilimnetic lake water and inoculations of photoautotrophs with a lake-enrichment culture both led to methane production even in the presence of oxygen, and the production was not affected by the addition of inorganic phosphate or methylated compounds. Methane production was also detected by in-lake incubations of lake water, and the highest production rate was 1.8-2.4 nM·h −1 at 6 m, which could explain 33-44% of the observed ambient methane accumulation in the same month. Temporal and spatial uncoupling between methanogenesis and methanotrophy was supported by field and laboratory measurements, which also helped explain the oversaturation of methane in the upper water column. Potentially methanogenic Archaea were detected in situ in the oxygenated, methane-rich epilimnion, and their attachment to photoautotrophs might allow for anaerobic growth and direct transfer of substrates for methane production. Specific PCR on mRNA of the methyl coenzyme M reductase A gene revealed active methanogenesis. Microbial methane production in oxygenated water represents a hitherto overlooked source of methane and can be important for carbon cycling in the aquatic environments and water to air methane flux. epilimnic methane peak | methanogens A lthough methane makes up <2 parts per million by volume (ppmv) of the atmosphere, it accounts for 20% of the total radiative forcing among all long-lived greenhouse gases (1). In the aquatic environments, methane is also an important substrate for microbial production (2). The prevailing paradigm is that microbial methanogenesis occurs primarily in anoxic environments (3, 4). A commonly observed paradox is methane accumulation in well-oxygenated waters (2, 5), which is often assumed to be the result of physical transport from anoxic sediment and water (6-8) or in situ production within microanoxic zones (9-11). Two recent studies challenged this paradigm and suggested that microbes in oligotrophic ocean can metabolize methylated compounds and release methane even aerobically (12, 13). These claims are not without caveats, because the amounts of methylated compounds added [1-10 μM methylphosphonate (12) and 50 μM dimethyl sulfoniopropionate (13)] were far higher than their environmental concentrations, and therefore, the ecological relevance remains obscure. Moreover, dissolved oxygen (DO) was not monitored during the long incubation (5-6 d), and the possibility that the experimental setups had become anoxic before methane production could not be dismissed.* Despite the unce...