Fostering Preservice Teachers’ Sense of Historical Agency through the use of Nonfiction Graphic Novels

Abstract

This article discusses a case study that explored the potential of nonfiction graphic novels to develop pre-service teachers’ understanding of agency in a social studies methods course. White pre-service teachers were aske'd to read one graphic novel and then add frames, re-narrate frames, and reflect on their decisions. The positionalities of researchers, who are White males, and participants were part of our analysis. The researchers found that pre-service teachers made revisions to the graphic novels to change the historical actors’ decisions: within the constraints of the historical situation's circumstances; to better fit their own ethical framework; and to critique the author's interpretation of the historical event and the amount of agency assigned to certain historical actors. We also reported findings related to shifts in understanding related to positionality. The pre-service teachers’ revisions demonstrated their understanding of historical actors’ ability to make choices; however, for most pre-service teachers those decisions were limited by, and insignificant in comparison to, the constraints of societal structures. Most pre-service teachers viewed these structures as operating outside of the realm of ethics that they used to articulate and identify agency, and thus, these structures were not responsive to changes in individual or collective agency. Implications are provided for social studies teacher educators.

graphic novel as a popular genre of book publishing in the context of modern design

“…These two components, based on a set of cultural and historical conventions, provide distanced from both types, but at the same time synergistic types of creativity. While the layout is based on metalinguistics concerning text and illustration, using text as a partial model of visual composition, typography transfers the visual component to the text, providing a partial visual mode of verbality (Clark & Camicia, 2014;Rocamora-Pérez et al, 2017).…”

Another Fever Year? Making sense of pandemics with a historical graphic novel

“…Graphic novels have been used in recent years to explore multimodal complexities (Connors, 2015; Kwon, 2020; Low and Jacobs, 2018; McClanahan and Nottingham, 2019; Smith and Pole, 2018), encourage empathy and compassion (Basinger, 2014; Chisholm et al, 2017), and learn about historical events or people (Bosma et al, 2013; Clark, 2014; Clark and Camicia, 2013). Historical graphic novels may provide opportunities for readers to attend to information of the past as well as make personal, emotion‐related connections (Chisholm et al, 2017).…”

‘Exhaustion --- Apparent on My Face’1: Fictionalization, Graphic Historiography and Data Visualization of Women’s Exclusion in Vidyun Sabhaney and Shohei Emura’s ‘Hard Times’

“…On the other hand, a comicbook history or fiction modeled on historical past firstly promotes a humanization and visualization of past and raw historical and statistical data in order to inform as well as emotionally affect the audience. According to Ben Lander, 'comic histories tend to revel in the minute personal details of everyday life' (Lander (2005), p. 117), and in Clark's view comicbook histories can guarantee a greater humanization of history (Clark (2013), p. 498). Moreover, the multimodality of comics promotes a multi-layered and multi-dimensional historical narration and data-analysis.…”