Foucault and Clinical Photography: An Analysis and Mitigation of the Clinical Gaze in Pediatric Craniofacial Plastic Surgery

Abstract

While objectification in medicine has been extensively critiqued as a philosophical concept dating back to the Ancient Greeks and contemporarily popularized by Michel Foucault, the impact of objectification through clinical photography in plastic surgery is often overlooked. Plastic surgery patients are by necessity subjected to the clinical gaze through clinical photography, which may lead to experiences of dehumanization and alienation from their physicians and surgeons. In this essay, we explore the concept of the clinical gaze in clinical photography from a structured philosophical lens, and offer one potential answer to this problem. First, we draw upon Foucault’s well-known and monumental critique of contemporary Western medical practice from Birth of the Clinic alongside a brief history of clinical photography to illustrate the problem of the “clinical gaze.” Then, we argue that mitigating the clinical gaze is critical for the flourishing of patients in general and plastic surgery patients in particular. Finally, we offer our attempt to mitigate the clinical gaze that was conducted by the Craniofacial Anomalies Program at the University of Michigan in 2014 as a demonstration of an upending of the power dynamic usually at play.