The thumb is acknowledged to contribute significantly to hand function, accounting for up to 40% of its overall capability. Consequently, injuries affecting the thumb can have a profound impact on the quality of life experienced by patients. When it comes to the surgical reconstruction of thumb injuries, the primary objective is to promptly provide coverage of the affected area with glabrous skin, thus preserving both the length and functionality of the thumb. Managing injuries specifically involving the thumb pulp can be particularly challenging due to the digit's size and vital role. Acquiring an adequate amount of glabrous soft tissue poses a difficulty in such cases. Various reconstructive approaches, encompassing a range of options on the reconstructive ladder, have been documented for thumb pulp injuries. The most popular options include pedicled flaps and free flaps obtained from both the hands and feet. However, a consensus regarding the optimal method for reconstructing the thumb pulp has yet to be reached. We present a case of total thumb pulp reconstruction for a 40 × 30 mm defect using the free thenar flap in a 65‐year‐old carpenter who sustained a work‐related injury. This flap was designed and raised on the superficial branch of the radial artery with a single subcutaneous vein and a branch of the palmar cutaneous nerve, the flap measured 43 × 32 mm. It was inset transversely with an end‐to‐end arterial anastomosis to the ulnar digital artery, venous anastomosis to the dorsal digital vein and nerve coaptation to the ulnar digital nerve. The postoperative course was uneventful, and the patient was discharged the following day without any complications. Eight months after surgery, the patient was extremely satisfied with the results of the procedure in terms of both function and appearance. The patient had experienced an improvement in function, sensation, and aesthetics. The patient had a QuickDASH disability/symptom score of 15.91 and a QuickDASH work module score of 18.75; the range of motion in the treated thumb was almost the same as the opposite thumb. The patient successfully resumed work three weeks following the procedure, initially with modified duties, and fully regained their work capacity within six weeks. As the patient's primary concern was their ability to return to work, the utilization of a free thenar flap offered several distinct advantages. These included minimal post‐operative complications, facilitated by a single operative site, allowing for reconstruction under regional anesthesia. Moreover, the procedure was conducted in a single stage, enabling the patient to be discharged on the same day without the need for further procedures. Furthermore, similar to several other reconstructive options for the thumb, the utilization of a free thenar flap offered the advantage of providing high‐quality, like‐for‐like glabrous tissue.