We present a unique variant of C1 fracture, which, at the best of our knowledge, has never been previously reported. This lesion consists in a lateral mass atlas fracture with a longitudinal separation of the transverse ligament that remains functionally preserved. We considered this lesion to be stable and treated the patient conservatively with good recovery. Even if many classifications of atlas fractures have been proposed, none of them ever described this uncommon variant. We debate about biomechanical aspects and therapeutic implication of the reported case.Keywords Atlas fracture Á Transverse ligament Á Cervical instability Á Cervical spine injury
Case reportA 42-year-old male is admitted to our emergency department after falling down the stairs provoking a cervicothoracic trauma. The dynamics of the accident had consisted in a fall from a staircase of around ten steps with receipt on the head. At admission the patient is awake and conscious; initial neurologic examination identifies no major disorder. Plain X-ray imagery of the cervical spine is non-conclusive. A total-body CT scan, including cerebral and cervical imagery, is performed showing a non-dislocated Anderson-Montesano type 1 fracture [1] of the right occipital condyle, a fracture of the atlas involving the right lateral mass and a congenital non-fusion of the anterior and posterior arches (Fig. 1). Other findings are a burst-fracture of the fourth thoracic vertebra and costal fractures of the second and eleventh rib on the right. The radiological examination is completed with a cervical MRI showing the massa lateralis fracture and a longitudinal separation of the transverse ligament (Fig. 2) which is separated lengthwise but its fibers are still intact (Scheme 1). No sign of atloaxial dislocation is evidenced.The fracture of the fourth thoracic vertebra is an unstable type B lesion and is stabilized surgically with a posterior spondylodesis. The C1 fracture is considered to be stable because of the functionally intact transverse ligament and treated conservatively by rigid collar immobilization during 3 months.The postoperative clinical course is uneventful and the patient is discharged from the hospital after 23 days. After 3 months the mobility of the cervical spine is re-established with the aid of physiotherapy.Five months after the trauma, a cervical CT scan shows the recovering fracture of the lateral mass and no evident lesion of the ligament (Fig. 3).
DiscussionFractures of the atlas occur in 2-13% of cervical spine injuries and represent 1-2% of all vertebral fractures [9].