Frailty measurement, prevalence, incidence, and clinical implications in people with diabetes: a systematic review and study-level meta-analysis

Abstract

Background Frailty, a state of increased vulnerability to adverse health outcomes, is important in diabetes management. We aimed to quantify the prevalence of frailty in people with diabetes, and to summarise the association between frailty and generic outcomes (eg, mortality) and diabetes-specific outcomes (eg, hypoglycaemia). Methods In this systematic review and study-level meta-analysis, we searched MEDLINE, Embase, and Web of Science for observational studies published between Jan 1, 2001 (the year of the original publication of the Fried frailty phenotype), to Nov 26, 2019. We included studies that assessed and quantified frailty in adults with diabetes, aged 18 years and older; and excluded conference abstracts, grey literature, and studies not published in English. Data from eligible studies were extracted using a piloted data extraction form. Our primary outcome was the prevalence of frailty in people with diabetes. Secondary outcomes were incidence of frailty and generic and diabetes-specific outcomes. Data were assessed by random-effects meta-analysis where possible and by narrative synthesis where populations were too heterogeneous to allow meta-analysis. This study is registered with PROSPERO, CRD42020163109. Findings Of the 3038 studies we identified, 118 studies using 20 different frailty measures were eligible for inclusion (n=1 375 373). The most commonly used measures of frailty were the frailty phenotype (69 [58%] of 118 studies), frailty (16 [14%]), and FRAIL scale (10 [8%]). Studies were heterogenous in setting (88 studies were community-based, 18 were outpatient-based, ten were inpatient-based, and two were based in residential care facilities), demographics, and inclusion criteria; therefore, we could not do a meta-analysis for the primary outcome and instead summarised prevalence data using a narrative synthesis. Median community frailty prevalence using frailty phenotype was 13% (IQR 9-21). Frailty was consistently associated with mortality in 13 (93%) of 14 studies assessing this outcome (pooled hazard ratio 1•51 [95% CI 1•30-1•76]), with hospital admission in seven (100%) of seven, and with disability in five (100%) of five studies. Frailty was associated with hypoglycaemia events in one study (<1%), microvascular and macrovascular complications in nine (82%) of 11 studies assessing complications, lower quality of life in three (100%) of three studies assessing quality of life, and cognitive impairment in three (100%) of three studies assessing cognitive impairment. 13 (11%) of 118 studies assessed glycated haemoglobin finding no consistent relationship with frailty. Interpretation The identification and assessment of frailty should become a routine aspect of diabetes care. The relationship between frailty and glycaemia, and the effect of frailty in specific groups (eg, middle-aged [aged <65 years] people and people in low-income and lower-middle-income countries) needs to be better understood to enable diabetes guidelines to be tailored to individuals with frailty. Funding Medical Rese...

The Impact of Frailty on the Effectiveness and Safety of Intensive Glucose Control and Blood Pressure–Lowering Therapy for People With Type 2 Diabetes: Results From the ADVANCE Trial

“…Intensive glucose treatment may usually be assumed safer in patients <65, and hence, this population may be more likely to receive strong glucose control agents or stronger doses, irrespective of their frailty status. According to a recent systematic review and meta-analysis of frailty in people with diabetes, the evidence on the effect of frailty in patients with diabetes aged <65 years is still limited ( 30 ).…”

Self-management interventions for Type 2 Diabetes: systematic review protocol focusing on patient workload and capacity support

“…This includes concordant (sharing similar risk factors, causes and management strategies) and discordant (distinct risk factors and management) long-term conditions 12 . Frailty, a state of reduced physiological reserve, is also highly prevalent in people with type 2 diabetes, affecting between 10 and 25% of people over the age of 60, as well as some in middle-age [13][14][15] . People with severe mental illness are also more than twice as likely to develop type 2 diabetes as people without 16 .…”

The Impact of and Interaction between Diabetes and Frailty on Psychosocial Wellbeing and Mortality in Ireland

“…To date, no studies have assessed this in the Irish context. In addition to psychosocial wellbeing, frailty predicts mortality in the general population [ 23 ] as well as amongst those with diabetes [ 24 , 25 ].…”