Free Radicals in Little Cigar Mainstream Smoke and the Potential Influence of Flavoring Chemicals on Free Radical Production

Abstract

Implementation of the Tobacco Control Act in 2009 banned characterizing flavors in cigarettes (except menthol and tobacco), but substitution has occurred by the continued availability of alternative flavored products (i.e., flavored little cigars). Little is known about how flavorants in noncigarette tobacco products impact human health. Thus, we investigated the impact of flavorants on free radical production in the mainstream smoke of little cigars. Gas- and particulate-phase free radical yields in mainstream smoke generated from 12 commercial little cigar brands and research little cigars and cigarettes were measured via electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy using the International Organization of Standardization (ISO) smoking protocol. Flavorants were extracted from unsmoked little cigars and analyzed by gas chromatography–mass spectroscopy. Gas- and particulate-phase radical yields from little cigars ranged from 13.5 to 97.6 and 0.453–1.175 nmol/unit, respectively. Comparatively, research cigarettes yielded an average of 4.9 nmol gas-phase radicals/unit and 0.292 nmol particulate-phase radicals/unit. From the products, 66 flavorants were identified, with each brand containing 4–24 individual flavorants. The free radical content was strongly correlated with the number of flavorants present in each cigar (r = 0.74, p = 0.01), indicating that highly flavored little cigars may produce higher levels of toxic free radicals. The presence of the flavorant ethyl methylphenylglycidate (strawberry) was associated with >2-fold higher levels of GP radicals (p = 0.001). Our results show that free radical delivery from little cigars is greater than that from research cigarettes and provide empirical evidence for the harmfulness of flavored tobacco products. Additionally, it demonstrates that flavorants present in combustible tobacco products can influence the levels of free radicals produced. Therefore, future tobacco product standards should consider little cigars.