Freedom and giving in game streams: A Foucauldian exploration of tips and donations on Twitch

Abstract

Twitch is a full‐fledged marketplace for game consumption, where gameplay is live streamed by players for the benefit of viewers/followers. Using Foucault's notions of freedom as a practice, we provide a psychosocial understanding of game stream engagement, and especially, user motivations for tipping streamers or donating to charity (i.e., “giving”). Following a netnographic approach, we analyse contributions to a large online forum and data gathered from 15 focus groups. We find that giving arises as an outcome of users exercising their freedom, whilst negotiating personal difficulties, for social gratification (e.g., status among peers), self‐determination (i.e., feeling control over one's life), and self‐extension (i.e., feeling affinity with others to achieve ideal self). By providing opportunities for self‐extension and self‐determination, which lead to better connectivity and stronger community support compared to social media, Twitch enables users to “give freely” (i.e., without obligation or compunction). Consequently, Twitch offers scope for more effective and mutually beneficial means of fundraising than traditional nonprofit marketing strategies, particularly by reaching younger target groups. Ultimately, the paper integrates three widely used theories under one (Foucauldian) metatheoretical perspective and highlights the central role of freedom in understanding game stream user engagement. Practical implications for nonprofit fundraising are also considered.

Improving the Health of Emerging Adult Gamers—A Scoping Review of Influences

“…Video game producers have a role in influencing the health of players passively [ 10 , 11 , 58 ], through gameplay mechanics [ 99 ] and the development and release of exergames and serious games [ 39 , 53 , 68 , 75 ]. Due to the advancements in the internet and streaming technologies, there has been a boom in content creators who develop influencer communities around gameplay [ 98 ]. Regarding technological advancements, there have been increases in the development and visibility of eSports organisations, eSports athletes [ 29 , 57 , 90 ], and large communities of gamers and viewers around their sports.…”

Motivations of playing digital games: A review and research agenda

“…Research on digital gaming has been evident in journals across various fields including science, business and humanities. A recent special issue from Psychology & Marketing on "Digital Gaming and Marketing" (Phau et al,) has published papers in the area of virtual reality games (Bender & Sung, 2021), gamification via mobile applications (Kunkel et al, 2021), gamers' divergent behaviour (Sharma et al, 2021), game mechanics and serous games for sustainability (Whittaker et al, 2021), game streaming (Yoganathan et al, 2021), game experience (Wang & Hang, 2021), and AI powered avatar (Butt et al, 2021). While searching in the databases, we came across hundreds of journals that published papers on digital games.…”

Status consumption and charitable donations: The power of empowerment

“…Both status products and the consumption of such products are needed for the effect to occur. We observed the effect with anonymous donations, suggesting that our results are unlikely to be explained by costly signaling (Griskevicius et al, 2010) or self-presentation concerns (Yoganathan et al, 2021).…”

“…Both status products and the consumption of such products are needed for the effect to occur. We observed the effect with anonymous donations, suggesting that our results are unlikely to be explained by costly signaling (Griskevicius et al, 2010) or self‐presentation concerns (Yoganathan et al, 2021). The next study further explores the importance of the consumption aspect by distinguishing having status consumption from wanting status consumption.…”