Continuous tubular crystallizers that can provide high yield and better control of crystal size would be of great interest to the industrial crystallization process. However, most continuous crystallizer designs face challenges either due to surface fouling or crystal breakage. In this paper, we explore the ability of slug-flow cooling crystallizers to continuously generate acetaminophen crystals using silicone oil as the continuous phase. Each slug acts as a crystallizer, and the crystals formed inside the dispersed phase avoid encrustation. Three crystallizer configurations were studied at a wide range of supersaturation and flow rates. It was found that a narrow crystal size distribution can be achieved at high flow rates and high supersaturation. Additionally, the average crystal size and the crystallization yield increased with supersaturation and residence time. The configuration of the tubular crystallizer was found to influence the crystallization yield by affecting the internal mixing in the slugs. With further studies, slug-flow cooling crystallizer can be developed for continuous crystallization of crystals with a narrow size distribution, polymorphic purity, and good yield.