From beef to beans: Eating motives and the replacement of animal proteins with plant proteins among Finnish consumers

Abstract

A better understanding of the motives underlying the adoption of sustainable and healthy diets is needed for designing more effective policies. The aim of the study was to examine how eating motives were associated with self-reported changes in the consumption of beef, beans, and soy products, i.e., changes related to reducing animal and increasing plant proteins. The study analysed a survey of an adult population living in Finland (N = 1048). The eating motives were measured with the Eating Motivation Survey (TEMS), which distinguishes between 15 eating motives. Six clusters of consumers based on self-reported changes in food choices were identified with latent class analysis (LCA). Four clusters had established food consumption patterns ("Beef only", "Beef and beans", "Beef, beans, and soy products", and "No beef"), one was undergoing a change, and one had attempted a change earlier. ANOVA with planned contrasts revealed that the motives relating to natural concerns, health, and weight control were higher, and convenience and price lower, among those who had an established diet including beans and soy products, as compared to those who consumed only beef. Those undergoing a dietary change expressed a higher endorsement of natural concerns as well as health, sociability, social image, and price motives than those with an established diet including beans and soy products. The results suggest that eating motives play an important role in changing towards more sustainable food consumption patterns in which meat/beef is replaced with plant proteins.

‘Taking the Politics out of Broccoli’: Debating (De)meatification in UK National and Regional Newspaper Coverage of the Meat Free Mondays Campaign

“…7 Associated with which is editorial independence as well as a reputation for high standards of journalism, and accuracy in reporting both nationally and internationally. 8 The impact on costs of food of a reduced meat/ no meat diet is given more detailed consideration in Vainio et al (2016). 9 Although a small number of articles assert that even vegetarianism -see 'demi' vegetarianism -is experiencing a positive shift in societal attitudes (e.g., Mesure, 12 July 2009, Independent).…”

“… The impact on costs of food of a reduced meat/ no meat diet is given more detailed consideration in Vainio et al . ().…”

New direction for NPD

“…Consumer choice should be at the core of getting food product development right. A switch or nudge to more sustainable dietary options is not only possible, it has already happened for protein choices, where increases in the consumption of more ‘eco‐friendly’ beans and lentils have occurred 6 . This would have been considered unthinkable not that long ago and it has been driven by consumer demand.…”

Effects of Soaking on the Functional Properties of Yellow‐Eyed Bean Flour and the Acceptability of Chocolate Brownies

“…One of the most common types of pulses grown in Canada are dried beans (Phaseolus vulgaris), and a growing body of research proposes that diets rich in beans have the potential to lower the risk of developing cardiovascular disease, various cancers, and diabetes (Bazzano, He, Ogden, Loria, & Vupputuri, 2001;Kushi, Meyer, & Jacobs, 1999). Although dried beans are gluten free (GF), their consumption in North America and in European Union countries is still low compared to countries, such as India and Lebanon, where pulses are a major part of the diet (IPSOS, 2010;Jallinoja, Niva, & Latvala, 2016). To increase the nutritional content of their GF processed foods, some food manufacturers have started to incorporate bean flours as ingredients to replace low-protein flours (for example, corn and rice) that are commonly used in GF products (Pellegrini & Agostoni, 2015;Szczygiel, Harte, Strasburg, & Cho, 2017).…”