From problem structuring to optimization: A multi-methodological framework to assist the planning of medical training

Abstract

Medical training is an intricate and long process, which is compulsory to medical practice and often lasts up to twelve years for some specialties. Health stakeholders recognise that an adequate planning is crucial for health systems to deliver necessary care services. However, proper planning needs to account for complexity related with the setting of medical school vacancies and of residency programs, which are highly influenced by multiple stakeholders with diverse perspectives and views, as well as by the specificities of medical training. Aiming at building comprehensive models with a potential to assist health decision-makers, this article develops a multi-methodological framework to assist the planning of medical training under such a complex environment. It combines the structuring of the objectives and specificities of the medical training problem with a Soft Systems Methodology through the CATWOE (Customer, Actor, Transformation, Weltanschauung, Owner, Environment) approach, and the formulation of a Mixed Integer Linear Programming model that considers all relevant aspects. Considering the specificities of countries based on a National Health Service structure, a multiobjective planning model emerges, informing on how many vacancies should be opened/closed per year in medical schools and in each specialty. This model aims at i) minimizing imbalances between medical demand and supply; ii) minimizing costs; and iii) maximizing equity across medical specialties. A case study in Portugal is explored so as to illustrate the applicability of the proposed multi-methodology, showing the relevance of proper structuring for planning models having the potential to inform health decision-makers and planners in practice.

Traps and Opportunities of Czech Small-Scale Beef Cattle Farming

“…In the soft system methodology, the CATWOE part usually enriches the root definitions and conceptual models [62,66]. For our purposes, we use the approach in the problem structuring phase to define the main stakeholders and elements of the system [67,68], which results in the definition of the model boundary. Table 1 summarises characteristics of the system in CATWOE framework-originally used for the proper formulation of root definitions [62], which helps to systemise and express the farmers' ideas of the reasons for cattle farming and the current situation in the field.…”

Change and improvement 50 years in the making: a scoping review of the use of soft systems methodology in healthcare

“…The extent of stakeholder involvement differed in the included studies. The number of consulted stakeholder groups varied from none in a study based on existing population data [ 28 ] to 20 [ 29 ]. A categorisation of the different stakeholders involved showed that the majority of studies ( n = 35, 71.4%) involved healthcare professionals such as nurses, physicians, pharmacists and dieticians.…”

Use of OR in earthquake operations management: A review of the literature and roadmap for future research

“…Greater use of problem structuring (e.g., hierarchical process modelling) and other Soft OR methods as part of facilitated workshops involving one or more stakeholders, we would suggest, would go a long way toward addressing this shortcoming. Such approaches are commonly used in healthcare settings [255,256] when dealing with complex and unstructured problems and or where they may be multiple groups of stakeholders with potentially conflicting views about a problem. EOM shares much in common with healthcare and would likely benefit by adopting Soft OR conceptual frameworks.…”