From the Public Space to the Prison Space: Regulation Polemic and the Implementation of Caning Law in Aceh

Abstract

The implementation of caning law in Aceh Province is still sporadic due to a lack of coordination among the government institutions involved in caning law. Then, the prison infrastructure to impose the canning law is also not ade-quate, and socialization has also not been fully carried out. Besides, in deter-mining the location of the caning, Islamic law requires the fulfillment of two principles namely “open space” and “visible” to the public. Furthermore, the law that guides the implementation of sharia in Aceh does not regulate detail of where the caning can be executed. Hence, the issues that need to be scruti-nized in this study are about shifting the norm from “open space" to “prison space” and why there is a disparity in determining the place of caning sentenc-es. This study uses a normative legal method by relying on secondary data. All collected data were analyzed by using qualitative analysis. The results show that there has been a shifting norm from "open space" to “prison space” in the application of the caning sentences in Aceh. This shift starts from the open area in the courtyard of the mosque to the prison area as a place to execute a caning sentence. This shifting also allows the people who meet certain criteria to wit-ness the execution of a caning sentence. In addition, there is also a disparity among the sharia courts due to the lack of facilities available in certain the sha-ria courts in Aceh. Hence, the Aceh government needs to improve the facilities of the sharia courts to be able to execute caning sentences.

IMPLEMENTATION OF ISLAMIC SHARIA LAWS IN EAST ACEH: The Acehnese Perspectives

“…The impact of execution, as the canning was carried on the public space, might brought the negative influence for underage spectators, thus, the system of execution was still questionable. 8 In addition, media also framed that the enforcement of sharia was often associated to violence. 9 In fact, if the government is capable of eliminating such issues, the enforcement of Islamic law could achieve its glory as in previous times.…”

The Aceh Governor’s Authority in Approving Regional Police Chief Appointments: An Analysis within the Unitary State Framework

“…The Indonesian Journal of the Social Sciences3) Aceh special autonomyThe Province of Nanggroe Aceh Darussalam, which was granted special autonomy as the Province of the Special Region of Aceh, offers the people of Aceh and their district or city governments a chance to rediscover their identity and develop their territory(Iskandar et al, 2022). Before the implementation of Law No.…”