The authors report the surgical treatment of an extensive right frontal sinus osteoma assisted by neuronavigation and reconstruction by a hydroxyapatite custom-made implant. The patient presents with ptosis, hypoglobus, and proptosis of the right eye, without any visual impairment. Computed tomographic (CT) scan showed a very large bony mass involving right frontal sinus and displacing the orbital roof. A stereolithographic model–guided planning was carried out to obtain a practical simulation of the surgical operation and it was submitted to a new CT scan to acquire the reference point to realize the neuronavigation assistance, and to achieve the template to realize the hydroxyapatite custom-made implant. Intraoperatively, with the help of neuronavigation assistance, osteotomies were performed by piezoelectric device. The reconstruction was made using a hydroxyapatite custom-made implant. The procedure was damage free, the bony mass was excised, and the orbital roof was repaired without any adverse effects. Postsurgical CT scan and scintigraphy showed a good reconstruction and a good-quality osteoblasts activity on the borders of the implant. Osteoma is a benign slow-growing bone tumor, usually involving the frontal sinus. Navigational assistance offers a very important help to perform safe osteotomies. Hydroxyapatite custom-made implant seems to be an excellent reconstructive method.