Background: Plasma phosphorylated ptau217 (ptau217) has been shown to be one of the most accurate diagnostic markers for Alzheimer disease (AD). No studies have compared the clinical performance of p tau217 as assessed by the fully automated Lumipulse and SIMOA ALZpath ptau217. Aim: To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of Lumipulse and SIMOA plasma ptau217 assays for AD. Methods: The study included 392 participants, 162 with AD, 70 with other neurodegenerative diseases (NDD) with CSF biomarkers and 160 healthy controls. Plasma ptau217 levels were measured using the Lumipulse and ALZpath SIMOA assays. The ability of ptau217 assessed by both techniques to discriminate AD from NDD and controls was investigated using ROC analyses. Results: Both techniques showed high internal consistency of ptau217 with similar correlation with CSF ptau181 levels. In head to head comparison, Lumipulse and SIMOA showed similar diagnostic accuracy for differentiating AD from NDD (area under the curve 0.952, 95%CI 0.927 0.978 vs 0.955, 95%CI 0.928 0.982, respectively) and HC (AUC 0.938, 95%CI 0.910 0.966 and 0.937, 95% CI0.907 0.967 for both assays). Conclusions: This study demonstrated the high precision and diagnostic accuracy of ptau217 for the clinical diagnosis of Alzheimer disease using either fully automated or semi-automated techniques.