In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, trehalose-6-phospahte synthase (Tps1) and trehalose-6-phosphate phosphatase (Tps2) are the main proteins catalyzing intracellular trehalose production. In addition to Tps1 and Tps2, two putative regulatory proteins with less clearly defined roles also appear to be involved with trehalose production, Tps3 and Tsl1. While this pathway has been extensively studied in laboratory strains of S. cerevisiae, we sought to examine the phenotypic consequences of disrupting these genes in wild strains. Here we deleted the TPS1, TPS2, TPS3 and TSL1 genes in four wild strains and one laboratory strain for comparison. Although some tested phenotypes were not shared between all strains, deletion of TPS1 abolished intracellular trehalose, caused inability to grow on fermentable carbon sources and resulted in severe sporulation deficiency for all five strains. After examining tps1 mutant strains expressing catalytically inactive variants of Tps1, our results indicate that Tps1, independent of trehalose production, is a key component for yeast survival in response to heat stress, for regulating sporulation, and growth on fermentable sugars. All tps2Δ mutants exhibited growth impairment on non-fermentable carbon sources, whereas variations were observed in trehalose synthesis, thermosensitivity and sporulation efficiency. tps3Δ and tsl1Δ mutants exhibited mild or no phenotypic disparity from their isogenic wild type although double mutants tps3Δ tsl1Δ decreased the amount of intracellular trehalose production in all five strains by 17% - 45%. Altogether, we evaluated, confirmed, and expanded the phenotypic characteristics associated trehalose biosynthesis mutants. We also identified natural phenotypic variants in multiple strains that could be used to genetically dissect the basis of these traits and then develop mechanistic models connecting trehalose metabolism to diverse cellular processes.