In this retrospective unicentric study, we analyzed the medical records of 11 patients who were surgically treated for CNS lymphoma, both primary and secondary, between 2009 and 2024. Given the rarity of CNS lymphomas and their diverse signs and symptoms based on tumoral location, our aim was to describe key aspects, such as clinical presentations and surgical management. A possible relationship between obesity and CNS lymphoma progression was investigated through an analysis of previous study findings. The literature suggests a wide spectrum of manifestations, from nausea and headaches to loss of equilibrium and speech impairment. A predominance of unsystematized balance disorders and epileptic seizures were affirmed. Notably, as emerged from our study, aphasia was a particularly interesting neurological symptom due to its rarity in the clinical features of CNSL. Other significant factors, such as tumor localization and perioperative phases, were thoroughly investigated, with the latter highlighted by an illustrative case report. Additionally, a literature review was included, comprising nine recent retrospective studies on the efficacy of surgical resection for patients diagnosed with PCNSL.