Oxidation of silicon is one of the most studied oxidation processes, mainly because it is a vital step in the fabrication of data chips for the computer industry. Several review articles have been published, 1-7 and since the end of the 1980s it has been generally accepted that the oxide growth occurs by transport of molecular oxygen through the oxide. This belief originates from the oxidation model proposed by Deal and Grove. 8 The Deal-Grove theory, and thereby the transport of molecular oxygen, cannot explain the initial stage of oxidation and has difficulties explaining the sensitivity of oxidation to interface modifications and contaminants (both in the gas phase and on the surface of the SiO 2 ). Several experimental results and arguments have been used to support molecular oxygen as the transported species. The main experimental results and arguments are 1-7 (i) a linear pressure dependence of the parabolic rate constant over a large range of temperatures and pressures; (ii) the activation energy of oxygen diffusion in SiO 2 is the same as for Ar, since O 2 and Ar have the same diameter; (iii) the lack of a straightforward dissociation mechanism for O 2 in SiO 2 ; and (iv) "conventional physicochemical wisdom." 3 Conventional physicochemical wisdom is based on the reaction order, thermodynamics, and the extreme reactivity of radicals (like atomic oxygen), i.e., that oxygen should react with the oxygen network when transported through the oxide, producing oxygen exchange. However, closer examination of these results does not prove that O 2 is the transported species and does not disfavor atomic oxygen at all as the transported species. Recent experiments have shown that (i) the dissociation rate of the oxygen molecules at the surface of the SiO 2 is much higher than the oxidation rate; 9 (ii) there is a coupling between the dissociation rate and the oxidation kinetics; 10 (iii) the oxygen exchange between O 2 molecules catalyzed by the SiO 2 surface (O 2 } O 2 ) varies with pressure raised to the second power; and (iv) there is an oxygen exchange at the internal interface. 11 The pressure dependency squared of the oxygen exchange (O 2 } O 2 ) indicates that the concentration of atomic oxygen depends linearly on the oxygen pressure and so explains a linear pressure dependency of the parabolic rate constant. All these experimental results favor atomic oxygen as the migrating species. In this study the different experimental results are used to argue for atomic and molecular oxygen, respectively, as the transported species. Each result is discussed as an argument for atomic or molecular oxygen as the transported species and given a mark on a seven-graded scale (ϩϩϩ to ϪϪϪ). Summing up the marks, atomic oxygen receives 17ϩ and 0Ϫ (⌺17ϩ), while molecular oxygen receives 3ϩ and 5Ϫ (⌺2Ϫ), leading us to conclude that atomic oxygen is much more likely to be the transported species.
ExperimentalA mass spectrometer setup was used to measure the oxygen exchange between O 2 molecules catalyzed by an SiO 2 surface (O 2 ...