Gaps in Reporting Greenhouse Gas Emissions by German Hospitals—A Systematic Grey Literature Review

Abstract

To mitigate the negative (health) consequences of climate change, the Paris Agreement demands a radical reduction of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The health sector contributes considerably to climate change worldwide. In Germany it is responsible for 6.7% of national GHG emissions. The transition to low-carbon hospitals requires detailed knowledge of the amount and sources of GHG emissions. This study aimed at capturing the status quo of GHG emission reporting by German hospitals and at examining characteristics of the reports. Therefore, we performed a grey literature review with pre-defined inclusion and exclusion criteria. The search strategy comprised hand-searching specific databases, targeted websites and web search engines via a standardized set of search terms. We found 232 German hospitals reporting their GHG emissions, representing 12% of all hospitals. Yet, only 62 hospitals (3%) met the inclusion criteria for further analysis. These reports do not comprise all energy-related GHG emissions, omit GHG emissions occurring up- and downstream of hospitals and mainly include CO2, but leave out other GHG. Consequently, there are severe gaps regarding GHG emissions reports of German hospitals. If Germany wants to comply with the Paris Agreement, hospitals need to be obliged to follow a standardized methodology to report and reduce GHG emissions.

‘Climate change mitigation is a hot topic, but not when it comes to hospitals’: a qualitative study on hospital stakeholders’ perception and sense of responsibility for greenhouse gas emissions

“…The health sector, and hospitals as part thereof, are seen as key to adapting to these health impacts. In contrast, hospitals’ role as an important emitter of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and thus a potential contributor to mitigation is less well known and hardly on the political agenda 2. 4.4% of global3 and 6.7% of German GHG emissions4 are estimated to stem from the health sector, including GHG emissions related to energy and upstream and downstream processes, for example, along supply chains and disposal of medical instruments or pharmaceuticals.…”

Environmental Performance Evaluation for a Small Scale Trigeneration System

“…The tertiary sector contributes significantly to climate change, accounting for 45% of final energy consumption and 20% of greenhouse gas emissions (Quitmann et al, 2021). In order to achieve the objectives set by the European Union in terms of GHG reduction, three action levels were applied (Strielkowski et al, 2021): reducing the need for energy by improving the insulation of existing end-users, improving energy efficiency by increasing the performance of various energy-consuming appliances, and replace fossil fuels with decarbonised energy sources, preferably renewable and sustainable.…”