Toxin-resistant predators may suffer costs from eating chemically-defended prey and do not feed exclusively on toxic prey. Common Gartersnakes (Thamnophis sirtalis) (Linnaeus, 1758) have been considered the drivers of an evolutionary arms race with highly toxic newts (Taricha spp.), which they consume with few or no deleterious effects. However, how frequently newts are consumed in nature is less clear. To address this question, we investigated the diets of T. sirtalis at a site in central Oregon where snakes have high levels of resistance and newts have high levels of tetrodotoxin in the skin. Because snake diets are difficult to quantify using traditional means, we used stable isotopes to estimate the proportion of T. sirtalis diets made up of newts. Our estimate for the proportion of T. sirtalis diet made up of T. granulosa at this site is 3.2%. Ambystoma salamanders were predicted to be the most important prey, followed by slugs, chorus frogs, and mice, with a very minor role for earthworms. Our results demonstrate that even though T. sirtalis are physiologically capable of consuming toxic prey, they do not often do so. Generalist predators can be exposed to very strong selection from, and exert reciprocal selection on even rarely eaten, chemically-defended prey.