SummaryMost studies of pattern formation and morphogenesis in metazoans focus on a small number of model species, despite the fact that information about a wide range of species and developmental stages has accumulated in recent years. By contrast, this article attempts to use this broad knowledge base to arrive at a classification of developmental types through which metazoan body plans are generated. This classification scheme pays particular attention to the diverse ways by which cell signalling and morphogenetic movements depend on each other, and leads to several testable hypotheses regarding morphological variation within and between species, as well as metazoan evolution.
Key words: Pattern formation, Morphogenesis, Body plan evolution, Evolution of development, Mechanisms of development
IntroductionThe conservation of developmental processes, especially that of genes and gene expression patterns (Gilbert, 2006; Carroll, 2001), has traditionally received a lot of attention in evolutionary developmental biology. Differences at the level of genes and gene interactions among metazoan groups have also been studied (Lynch and Wagner, 2008). However, few studies have integrated the available information about different stages of development to understand the commonalities and differences in the overall process of development among metazoa. Earlier work identified gross developmental similarities and differences between metazoan groups that led to their classification into three types of development (Davidson, 1991;Davidson et al., 1995;Wray, 2000). These similarities in development are suggested to relate to similarities in the body plan or in the life cycle of the different species.This article introduces a classification scheme that incorporates the information about additional species and about later stages of development that has accumulated since the publication of these previous reviews. I also propose new hypotheses about the relationship between signalling and morphogenetic movements in the classification of developmental types. Particular attention is given to the distinction between morphostatic and morphodynamic developmental mechanisms (Salazar-Ciudad et al., 2003). In morphostatic mechanisms, major signalling events occur before the onset of morphogenetic movements, whereas in morphodynamic mechanisms, cell signalling and morphogenetic mechanisms occur at the same time or in a closely interlinked manner (Fig. 1). Previous work (Salazar-Ciudad and Jernvall, 2004) suggests that this distinction has important implications for our understanding of developmental dynamics and for how development affects evolution. However, this previous work focused on individual developmental mechanisms that act only between specific developmental stages. Here, the focus is not on specific stages, but instead on the entire period of development. Thus, the previous classifications are revised to take into account the diversity of events in metazoa over the course of development. On the basis of the relative timing and of...