“…Furthermore, the unusual features of the MC-252 spill, i.e., its occurrence in deep water and extensive subsurface dispersant treatment leading to a deep-water plume of highly dispersed oil, make it highly likely that some MOS formed below the photic zone. For example, it is known that hydrocarbondegrading enrichments in the dark (Baelum et al, 2012) as well as pure cultures of hydrocarbon-degrading bacteria (Alcanivorax borkumensis, Omarova et al, 2019;Marinobacter hydrocarbonoclasticus, Vaysse et al, 2011;Halomonas sp., Gutierrez et al, 2013b; and Alteromonas sp., Gutierrez et al, 2018), can form EPS-rich films around oil droplets, sometimes creating flocs (Gutierrez et al, 2013a(Gutierrez et al, ,b, 2018, even causing gelation (Radwan et al, 2017), and microbial coatings on oil droplets will alter their surface properties and may result in reduced coalescence (Omarova et al, 2019). Unfortunately, the oil concentrations used in many of these studies were very high (up to 5,000 ppm), and nutrient levels were often many orders of magnitude above those available in the open sea (Bejarano et al, 2014;Wade et al, 2016), so it is not clear how well they mimic what happens in the ocean.…”