Gender differences in leadership style, job stress and mental health in male ‐ and female ‐ dominated industries

Abstract

A number of writers have suggested that when men dominate numerically in an industry, women in that industry experience pressure to alter their leadership style, which in turn impacts on their mental health. These assertions, based largely on limited research findings and anecdotal evidence, were tested empirically. Specifically, the study investigated the impact of working in either a male‐ or female‐dominated industry on the leadership style, stress levels and mental health of 60 women and 60 men managers. As hypothesized, women and men in male‐dominated industries did not differ in interpersonal orientation, whereas in female‐dominated industries women were more interpersonally oriented than men. Consistent with predictions, women did report more pressure from their jobs than men, with women in male‐dominated industries reporting the highest level of pressure from discrimination. Although there was no overall difference between women and men's mental health, there was a difference in the pattern of relationships between leadership style and mental health. Women in male‐dominated industries reported worse mental health when they utilized an interpersonally oriented leadership style, whereas men in male‐dominated industries reported better mental health when they utilized such a leadership style. These findings suggest that both gender and the gender ratio of the industry influence leadership style, stress and mental health, and as such contribute to our understanding of the barriers to women working in senior management roles in male‐dominated industries.

The Trade-Offs between Job Satisfaction, Performance, and Locus of Control on Job Performance: Case of Sohana Outfitters Company

“…However, the deeper probe into the data revealed female workers are more stressed than their male counterparts given their education level. This finding is consistent with previous research highlighting the gender-basedpower workspaces influencing perceived stress and productivity (Gardiner and Tiggemann, 1999). …”

“…Customer satisfaction's influence on job performance has been a volatile issue. For instance, Gupta and Zeithaml [15] found a positive relationship between customer satisfaction and financial performance, while Bernhardt, Dunthu and Kennett [16] found just the opposite.…”

Ideal leader profiles in the Icelandic business sector: Evidence of uniformity of followers’ attitudes

“…Nevertheless, the industries where leaders work can have an impact here. In male-dominated industries, women tend to have similar leadership styles to men in those industries, and may even demonstrate a more stereotypically masculine style of leadership than males (Gardiner and Tiggemann, 1999). These findings support Kanter's (1977) conclusions, where she states that women alter their management style when in a minority, in order to lessen differences perceived by men.…”

Female entrepreneurs in transition economies: insights from Albania, Macedonia and Kosovo

“…Management skills and approaches have also been researched (Buttner, 2001;Gardiner and Tiggemann, 1999). Female entrepreneurs, before they start their businesses, need to evaluate their managerial skills which impact the success or failure of the enterprise.…”