Gender differences in professional identities and development of engineering skills among early career engineers in Finland

Abstract

Formation of professional identity is a process where individuals attempt to bring together the social expectations set for them as professionals and their own interests and values. The cultural landscape of engineering is masculine in various ways, which can be challenging especially for female engineers who need to match the cultural expectations with their personal identities. So far, few studies have compared the professional identities of early-career men and women engineers. This study aims to understand the professional identities of newly graduated Finnish male and female engineers by analysing their perceptions of the importance and development of professional engineering skills. An analysis of crosssectional survey data of more than 4000 early-career engineers suggests some gender differences related to professional identities and indicates that the observed differences in values and perceived skills can put women at a greater risk of dropping out of an engineering career.

‘College choice’ under the COVID-19 pandemic: Sustainability of engineering campuses for future enrollments

“…They might be considering faculty as facilitators and mentors in sustaining their career paths [ 54 , 56 ]. In accordance with the findings of [ 389 ], this might be the reason why these students have identified faculty as a long-term influencer for their inclusion in engineering professions.…”

Taking action in the first five years to increase career equality: the impact of professional relationships on young women’s advancement

“…Current research reveals the lack of investment in gender diversity and a disconnect in resources being invested to improve the lack of belonging new hires feel (The 3% Movement, 2017;Lum, 2019), suggesting that the industry needs additional resources to implement impactful programming aimed to address this issue. Additionally, gender is an integral part of adapting to and integrating into organizational life (Acker, 2006;Naukkarinen & Bairoh, 2022;Nyström, 2010). Gregory (2016) reported that the experiences of women in advertising's creative departments revealed hostility, that women were unwelcome, and men creative directors and clients who were men provided an anti-women sense in the agency.…”

“…Current research reveals the lack of investment in gender diversity and a disconnect in resources being invested to improve the lack of belonging new hires feel (The 3% Movement, 2017; Lum, 2019), suggesting that the industry needs additional resources to implement impactful programming aimed to address this issue. In addition, gender is an integral part of adapting to and integrating into organizational life (Acker, 2006; Naukkarinen and Bairoh, 2022; Nyström, 2010).…”

The Influence of Innovative Characteristics, Work Readiness, and Vocational Self-Concept on Employability of Vocational College Students

“…Research done by Joensuu-Salo et al (2015) says that men show stronger interest and higher risk taking to become entrepreneurs than women. According to Naukkarinen and Bairoh (2022), male vocational engineering students develop creativity easier compared to female students, that will be helpful in future work. Even in China, Zeng et al (2022) find that male vocational students are more driven and exhibit elevated energy when it comes to adapting to work.…”